Market data infrastructure under Regulation NMS is the set of plans, processors and definitions through which quotes and trades in US-listed stocks are collected from every trading venue and published as one consolidated stream. Regulation NMS, adopted by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 2005 and codified at 17 CFR 242.600 to 242.614, relies on this data to calculate the national best bid and offer (NBBO) and to enforce order protection.
The family has two layers. The older layer consists of joint industry plans filed by self-regulatory organisations and the processors that run them, which produce the consolidated tape. The newer layer comes from the SEC's 2020 Market Data Infrastructure Rule, which redefined the content of consolidated data and created a decentralised model of competing consolidators and self-aggregators. Exchanges, broker-dealers, market data vendors and regulators all depend on these arrangements, and their fees and governance have long been disputed.
National Market System Plan (NMS Plan)
A national market system plan (NMS plan) is a joint plan filed with the SEC by two or more self-regulatory organisations, such as the stock exchanges and FINRA, to act together on a market-wide function. Under Rule 608 of Regulation NMS, a plan and any amendment must be published for comment and approved by the SEC, which may also propose changes itself. Well-known examples are the plans that govern consolidated quotation and trade data for different groups of stocks, the plan that created the consolidated audit trail, and the Limit Up-Limit Down plan that sets price bands to stop sudden swings in individual stocks. Each plan is run by an operating committee of participant representatives, and voting rules, fees and the role of non-participant advisers are set in the plan. Critics have argued that the exchange groups that run the data plans also sell competing proprietary feeds, creating a conflict of interest.
Effective Transaction Reporting Plan
An effective transaction reporting plan is a plan, approved by the SEC under Regulation NMS, that governs how completed trades in listed equity securities are reported, collected, processed and disseminated as last-sale information. Every exchange and FINRA, which covers trades executed off exchange through its trade reporting facilities, must report trades within a short time so that the public tape shows prices and volumes from all venues. The two main US plans have long divided securities by listing market: one covers stocks listed on the New York Stock Exchange and other non-Nasdaq exchanges, and the other covers Nasdaq-listed stocks. Each plan is paired with a quotation plan and has a processor that consolidates its data. The plan sets fees for subscribers, distinguishing professional and non-professional users, and shares the net revenue among participants according to a formula tied to their trading and quoting activity.
Securities Information Processor (SIP)
A securities information processor (SIP) is the entity that collects quotes and trade reports from all participants in a data plan, calculates the national best bid and offer, and distributes the consolidated feed to subscribers. Regulation NMS calls the operator of a plan's processing a plan processor, and it must register with the SEC. For NYSE-listed and other non-Nasdaq stocks, the processor has been run by a subsidiary of the NYSE's parent group; for Nasdaq-listed stocks, Nasdaq runs it. Brokers use SIP data to display quotes to retail customers and to check order protection, while market data vendors redistribute it widely. The main criticism is latency: data must travel from each venue to a central processor and back out, so firms that buy direct proprietary feeds and use colocation see prices sooner. SIPs have also been criticised for thin content, since they long carried only the best quotes.
Core Data
Core data is the defined set of information that makes up consolidated market data for each NMS stock under the SEC's 2020 Market Data Infrastructure Rule. Before that rule, the consolidated feed carried mainly each exchange's best round-lot bid and offer and last-sale reports. The new definition expanded it to include several price levels of depth of book beyond the best quotes, quotations in odd lots at prices better than the best round-lot quote, information about opening, closing and reopening auctions, and regulatory data such as price bands and short-sale restrictions. The rule also tied the definition of a round lot to the stock's price, so that a high-priced share trades in smaller round lots. The SEC presented the change as narrowing the information gap between consolidated and proprietary feeds. Implementation depends on exchange plan amendments and has been phased.
Competing Consolidator
A competing consolidator is a firm, registered with the SEC under the 2020 Market Data Infrastructure Rule, that receives the data content underlying core data directly from exchanges and FINRA, builds consolidated market data and sells it to subscribers. The model is meant to replace the exclusive SIPs with several commercial providers that compete on speed, reliability and price. Under the rule, exchanges must make their data available to competing consolidators on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms, and the consolidators are subject to SEC oversight of their systems, including operational standards similar to those for other critical market infrastructure. During a transition period the existing processors continue to operate alongside the new entrants. Supporters expected lower latency and richer content. Exchanges challenged elements of the rule, and the timing of the move from SIPs to competing consolidators has slipped, so the real-world effect has developed slowly and remains subject to further SEC action.
Self-Aggregator
A self-aggregator is a broker-dealer that collects the data content underlying core data directly from the exchanges and FINRA and assembles consolidated market data solely for its own internal use. It does the same job as a competing consolidator but does not sell the result to others, so it does not need to register as a consolidator. The option suits large trading firms that already take direct feeds from every venue and want to generate the NBBO and depth information themselves, for example to meet best execution duties or to drive smart order routing, rather than buying a consolidated feed. A self-aggregator still has to pay the exchanges for the data it receives. It cannot redistribute consolidated market data to customers or affiliates, which separates it from a competing consolidator and from a vendor that redistributes a SIP feed.
How the parts fit together
| Element | Role | Created by |
|---|---|---|
| NMS plan | Joint governance of a market-wide function | SROs, approved by the SEC |
| Transaction reporting plan | Rules for reporting and publishing trades | SROs, approved by the SEC |
| SIP | Exclusive processor of consolidated data | Plan participants |
| Core data | Content of consolidated data | SEC rule, 2020 |
| Competing consolidator | Commercial seller of consolidated data | SEC rule, 2020 |
| Self-aggregator | Broker building data for own use | SEC rule, 2020 |
External links
Ref 1100001872