A lock-up agreement is a contract in which the existing shareholders of a company that is going public promise not to sell or otherwise dispose of their shares for a set period after the offering. The parties bound are usually the founders, directors, executives, employees and pre-offering investors such as venture capital and private equity funds. The agreement is made with the underwriters of the offering.
Lock-ups are a standard feature of an initial public offering in the United States and most other markets. The usual period is 180 days, though it can be shorter or longer. In the United States the arrangement is a matter of contract and market practice, not a requirement of securities law, but its terms must be described in the prospectus. Some other jurisdictions and stock exchanges impose lock-ups on controlling shareholders by rule.
Purpose
In a typical offering only a minority of the company's shares is sold to the public, and the rest remains with insiders. If those holders were free to sell at once, the supply of shares could swamp demand in the first weeks of trading. The lock-up keeps that supply off the market while a trading history develops, which helps the underwriting banks place the issue and stabilize its price.
The restriction also serves as a signal. New investors know less about the company than its managers do, and a commitment by insiders to hold their shares for months gives some assurance that they are not using the offering to exit before bad news emerges. It keeps management's interests tied to the share price during the first reporting periods as a listed company.
Typical terms
- Scope. The agreement normally covers sales, pledges, short sales and derivative transactions that would transfer the economic exposure of the shares, not only outright sales.
- Exceptions. Common carve-outs allow gifts, transfers to family trusts and to affiliates, provided the recipient accepts the same restriction, and sales needed to pay tax on vesting share awards.
- Waiver. The lead underwriter can release some or all holders early at its discretion, for example to allow a follow-on offering when the share price has risen strongly.
- Staggered release. Some agreements free a portion of the shares early, often for employees, if the price stays above a set level or after the first earnings report.
The company itself usually agrees not to issue further shares during the same period, apart from those under employee plans. A lock-up is separate from the legal limits on resale of unregistered shares and from rules on insider trading, which continue to apply after it ends.
Expiry
When the lock-up ends, a large number of shares becomes eligible for sale on a known date, often several times the free float created by the offering. Academic studies of US offerings, including a widely cited paper by Laura Field and Gordon Hanka published in 2001, have found that share prices fall by an average of one to three percent around the expiry date and that trading volume rises permanently. The effect is larger for companies backed by venture capital, whose funds tend to sell or distribute shares to their own investors soon afterward.
The decline is notable because the date is public from the outset, so an efficient market should already reflect it. Explanations offered include a greater than expected volume of insider selling, limits on short selling in stocks with a small float, and investor demand that is less elastic than theory assumes. The average hides wide variation, and many shares rise through the expiry. Analysts track upcoming expiry dates, and the number of shares to be released, as a known supply event.
Variations
Lock-ups are also used outside the traditional offering. In a merger with a SPAC, the sponsor and the target's shareholders commonly accept restrictions, with the sponsor's often lasting a year. In a direct listing, where a company lists existing shares without an underwritten sale, there has often been no lock-up at all, so insiders can sell from the first day. In a secondary offering by a listed company, executives and selling shareholders usually agree to a shorter restriction of 30 to 90 days.
In mergers and acquisitions, the same phrase has a different meaning. It can refer to an undertaking by a target's major shareholder to accept a bid, or to an arrangement that gives a favoured bidder an option over shares or key assets in order to deter rivals.
Criticism
Lock-ups delay but do not remove selling pressure, and they concentrate it on particular dates. Employees can find that the share price has fallen sharply before they are permitted to sell, while tax on their awards may already be due. The underwriter's power to waive the restriction selectively has drawn criticism where favoured holders were released early with little notice to the market. Disclosure rules in the United States now require public notice before the release of directors and officers in most cases.