A liquidation preference is a contractual right attached to preferred shares that entitles their holders to receive a specified amount from the proceeds of a sale, merger or winding-up of the company before anything is paid to holders of common stock. The amount is usually defined as a multiple of the price originally paid for the shares, plus any dividends that have been declared or have accrued but not been paid.
The term is one of the main economic provisions in venture capital and growth equity financing. Investors receive preferred stock, while founders and employees hold common shares or options over them. The preference protects investors if the company is sold for less than hoped, and it determines how the proceeds of any exit are divided. It is set out in the term sheet and then in the company's charter.
When the preference applies
Despite its name, the right is rarely exercised in a formal liquidation. Financing documents define a wider set of deemed liquidation events, which normally include an acquisition of the company, a merger in which existing shareholders lose control, and a sale of substantially all its assets. An initial public offering is usually not such an event. Preferred shares typically convert into common shares at a listing, and the preference falls away. In an insolvency, creditors are paid before any shareholder, so the preference only ranks holders of equity among themselves.
Main terms
- Multiple. A 1x preference returns the original investment. Multiples of 1.5x, 2x or more return a larger sum and appear mainly when capital is scarce or a company is in difficulty.
- Participation. Non-participating preferred holders must choose between taking the preference and converting to common to share in the proceeds by percentage. Holders of participating preferred stock take the preference first and then also share in the remainder alongside common holders.
- Cap. Participation may be limited to a total return, such as three times the investment, above which the holder is better off converting.
- Seniority. Where there have been several funding rounds, later investors may rank ahead of earlier ones, which is called a stacked structure, or all series may share equally in proportion to their claims.
Payout formulas and example
For non-participating preferred shares, the holder receives the greater of two amounts:
For fully participating preferred shares:
- is the preference multiple.
- is the amount invested.
- is the holder's fully converted ownership percentage, as shown in the cap table.
- is the sale proceeds available to shareholders.
Suppose an investor pays 10 million for 20 percent of a company with a 1x non-participating preference. If the company is sold for 30 million, the preference is worth 10 million and conversion would give million, so the investor takes 10 million and the common holders share 20 million. If the sale price is 100 million, conversion gives million, which exceeds the preference, so the investor converts. The two choices are equal at a sale price of million.
With a participating preference and the same 30 million sale, the investor receives million and the common holders receive 16 million. At a sale price of 8 million, below the amount invested, the investor in either case receives all 8 million and the common holders nothing.
Effect on founders and employees
The total of all preferences across funding rounds is known as the preference stack or overhang. A company that has raised 80 million with 1x preferences must be sold for more than 80 million before common holders receive anything, whatever the headline valuation of its last round. Employees holding options can therefore find them worth little in a modest sale even though the company's stated value was high. This gap is one reason a headline valuation based on the latest preferred share price overstates the worth of the common shares. Heavy preferences are often agreed in a down round, when investors accept a lower price only with stronger protection.
A large overhang can also distort decisions. Managers whose common shares are under water have little reason to support a sale that would benefit only investors, and buyers sometimes set aside a separate payment to keep them. Preferences interact with dilution as well, since each new round adds to the stack ahead of the common shares.
Market practice
In the United States venture market, a 1x non-participating preference has long been the most common term for early rounds and is regarded as the standard balanced position. Participating and multiple preferences become more frequent in downturns and in later-stage or distressed financings. The term is negotiated by the lead investor for all participants in the round. Similar priority rights exist in private equity structures and in convertible preferred stock issued by listed companies, where the preference is a fixed amount per share.