The Kyoto Protocol is an international treaty, adopted in Kyoto, Japan, in December 1997 under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), that set legally binding limits on greenhouse gas emissions for a group of industrialised countries. It entered into force on 16 February 2005. For finance, its lasting importance is that it created the first international carbon markets: tradable emission allowances and project-based credits that turned a tonne of avoided emissions into something that could be priced, bought and sold.
The protocol covered six gases, measured together in carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e). Its binding targets applied only to the developed and transition economies listed in its Annex B; developing countries, including China and India, had no caps. It was largely superseded by the Paris Agreement of 2015, which asks every country to set its own targets, but many of its market structures survive in later systems.
Targets and commitment periods
In the first commitment period, 2008 to 2012, Annex B parties agreed to cut their combined emissions by about 5% below 1990 levels, with individual targets for each country. The European Union took a joint target and divided it among its members. Each capped party received an allocation of assigned amount units (AAUs), each worth one tonne of CO2e, equal to its permitted emissions for the period. At the end, a country had to hold enough units to cover its actual emissions.
A second commitment period, 2013 to 2020, was set by the Doha Amendment agreed in 2012. Fewer countries took on targets in that round, and the amendment only entered into force at the very end of the period. After 2020 the protocol no longer set new obligations, and climate co-operation moved to the Paris framework.
The flexible mechanisms
The protocol let countries meet part of their targets through three market-based tools, often called the flexible mechanisms. The idea was that cutting a tonne of emissions has the same effect on the climate wherever it happens, so cuts should be made where they are cheapest.
- International emissions trading. Capped countries with spare AAUs could sell them to countries that expected to exceed their limits.
- The Clean Development Mechanism (CDM). Projects that reduced emissions in developing countries, such as wind farms or methane capture at landfills, could earn certified emission reductions (CERs), which capped countries and companies could use toward their targets.
- Joint Implementation (JI). Similar projects in other capped countries, mostly in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union, earned emission reduction units (ERUs), which were converted from the host country's own AAUs.
The CDM was supervised by an executive board under the UN, which approved methods for measuring reductions and registered projects. A share of the CERs issued was set aside to finance an Adaptation Fund for poorer countries. The CDM's test of additionality, the requirement that a project would not have happened without carbon revenue, became a model for later offset standards.
Carbon markets built on the protocol
The best-known market linked to Kyoto is the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), launched in 2005 as the European Union's main tool for meeting its Kyoto target. It caps emissions from power stations and heavy industry and lets companies trade allowances. For several years EU companies could also use CERs and ERUs for compliance, which tied the price of Kyoto credits to European demand.
A market in CER futures, forwards and options grew up on exchanges such as ICE Futures Europe and the European Energy Exchange (EEX), and banks and trading houses built desks to finance projects and arbitrage between credits and allowances. Prices for CERs fell sharply in the early 2010s, when the EU restricted their use, the 2008 recession lowered emissions and a large supply of credits came to market. That collapse shaped the design of later carbon credit schemes and the voluntary carbon market.
Participation and criticism
The United States signed the protocol in 1998 but never ratified it, and in 2001 the administration of President George W. Bush said it would not pursue ratification, citing the economic cost and the absence of caps on large developing economies. Canada withdrew in 2012. The treaty could only take effect once enough industrialised countries had joined, and Russia's ratification in 2004 brought it over that threshold.
Critics argued that the targets were too modest and covered too small a share of global emissions, especially as emissions from developing economies rose. Others pointed to "hot air", the large surplus of AAUs held by former Soviet countries whose emissions had fallen with the collapse of heavy industry after 1990. Some CDM projects, notably those destroying industrial gases, were criticised for earning credits far above their real climate value. Supporters answered that the protocol built the measurement, reporting and verification systems that later climate finance and carbon pricing rely on.
Legacy
The Paris Agreement replaced binding top-down caps with nationally determined contributions, but its Article 6 carries forward the idea of international trading in emission reductions. Questions over whether old CDM credits and projects can move into the new system were a long-running issue in the negotiations. In financial terms, the protocol is the origin of compliance carbon markets as an asset class within commodities trading.
External links
Ref 1180001996