A just transition is the principle that the move from a high-carbon to a low-carbon economy should be managed so that its costs and benefits are shared fairly. It focuses on the workers, communities and countries that depend on fossil fuel extraction, carbon-intensive industry or vulnerable land use, and on making sure that closing coal mines or power plants does not leave them without jobs, income or public services.
The idea links climate policy with labour, social and development policy. It is a recurring theme in negotiations under the United Nations climate process, in national plans such as nationally determined contributions, and increasingly in the strategies of banks, investors and development lenders. It sits alongside climate change mitigation and adaptation as a test of whether climate action is socially sustainable.
Origins
The phrase originated in the North American labour movement in the 1980s and 1990s, when trade unions argued that workers displaced by environmental regulation of toxic and polluting industries deserved support, retraining and income protection. It was taken up by international union federations in the 2000s and moved into climate diplomacy.
The preamble to the Paris Agreement of 2015 refers to the imperatives of a just transition of the workforce and the creation of decent work and quality jobs in line with nationally defined development priorities. In the same year the International Labour Organization published guidelines for a just transition towards environmentally sustainable economies and societies for all, agreed by governments, employers and workers. Later UN climate conferences adopted further declarations, and a dedicated work programme on just transition was established in 2022.
Key elements
Definitions vary, but most frameworks combine several elements:
- Social dialogue. Workers, employers, governments and affected communities take part in planning the transition rather than having it imposed.
- Decent work and skills. New jobs in sectors such as renewable energy and energy efficiency should be of good quality, and displaced workers should have access to retraining and redeployment.
- Social protection. Pensions, income support and health cover help workers and households through closures.
- Regional economic development. Diversification and investment help coal and oil regions replace lost tax revenue and economic activity.
- Fair burden sharing. Measures such as carbon taxes are designed so that low-income households are not hit hardest, and wealthier countries support poorer ones.
Just Energy Transition Partnerships
Just Energy Transition Partnerships (JETPs) are financing arrangements between a developing country and a group of donor governments and development banks to speed up the move away from coal while supporting affected workers and communities. The first was announced for South Africa at the United Nations climate conference in Glasgow in 2021, with an initial pledge of 8.5 billion US dollars from France, Germany, the United Kingdom, the United States and the European Union. Partnerships for Indonesia and Vietnam followed in 2022, with larger headline sums that included expected private finance, and a partnership with Senegal followed in 2023.
JETPs combine grants, concessional loans, guarantees and commercial finance, and are coordinated through country investment plans. They have been criticised for relying heavily on loans rather than grants, for slow disbursement and for uncertainty after changes in donor government policy, but they remain the main model for country-level transition finance.
The role of finance
Banks, investors and development institutions affect the transition through what they finance and on what terms. Development finance institutions and multilateral development banks fund early coal plant retirement, grid expansion, regional diversification and social programmes, often through blended finance structures that bring in private lenders. In the European Union, the Just Transition Mechanism, part of the European Green Deal, includes a dedicated fund for regions most dependent on fossil fuels.
Private financial institutions increasingly consider just transition in their transition finance plans, for example by assessing the social effects of exiting coal clients and engaging companies on how they treat workers during closures. Investors see social risk as part of transition risk: abrupt, unmanaged closures can trigger strikes, political backlash and policy reversals that affect asset values.
Criticism and debates
Critics argue that the term is loosely defined and can be used to justify delay, for example to extend the life of fossil fuel assets in the name of protecting jobs. Others say commitments by wealthy countries remain small compared with the needs of developing economies, and that financing through loans adds to debt burdens. Labour organisations warn that new clean energy jobs are not always in the same places, or of the same quality, as those lost. Supporters reply that without attention to fairness, the political support needed for deep emissions cuts is unlikely to hold.
External links
Ref 1100001427