Insurance rests on a few linked ideas: which risks an insurer is willing to take, how the insurer itself can fail by mispricing them, how outsiders judge whether it is strong enough to pay claims, and what protection remains for policyholders if it is not. This page covers four terms that together describe that chain, from the edge of what can be insured to the safety net of last resort.
Insurers, regulators, brokers and buyers all use these ideas. A risk that is uninsurable cannot be sold at a workable price, while an insurer that prices insurable risks badly takes on underwriting risk. Rating agencies such as AM Best assess how likely an insurer is to meet its obligations, and state guaranty funds step in after an insolvency, though only within limits. Each section below stands on its own.
Uninsurable Risk
An uninsurable risk, sometimes called an uninsurable peril, is one that insurers will not cover, or cannot price, on normal terms. Insurance works when many people face similar and independent chances of a loss that is accidental, definite, measurable and not catastrophic for the whole pool, so that the law of large numbers makes total claims predictable. Risks that fail these tests are usually excluded. Typical examples are wear and tear, deliberate acts, war and nuclear events in standard policies, and the outcome of a business venture, which is a speculative risk because it can produce a gain as well as a loss.
A buyer must also have an insurable interest in what is covered, meaning a real financial stake. Where cover is unavailable from ordinary insurers, specialist markets, government schemes or self-insurance may fill part of the gap, and many policies list unwanted risks as exclusions.
Underwriting Risk
Underwriting risk has two meanings. For an insurer, it is the risk that claims and expenses will exceed the premiums collected because risks were mispriced, selected badly or hit by unexpected losses. Such risk is driven by adverse selection, moral hazard and catastrophic events, and it is measured through the loss ratio and the combined ratio, where a combined ratio above 100 per cent means an underwriting loss. Insurers manage it through careful underwriting, pricing, limits and reinsurance.
In securities, an underwriter faces a different risk. In a firm commitment offering, the underwriting bank buys the whole issue from the company and resells it, so it bears the loss if investors will not buy at the offer price, for example in an initial public offering that meets weak demand. Best-efforts deals leave this risk with the issuer.
State Guaranty Fund
A state guaranty fund is a US state-run safety net that pays or continues policyholders' claims when a life, health or property and casualty insurer becomes insolvent. Each state, together with the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico, has such associations, usually set up under a state law modelled on one from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. They are normally funded by assessments on the licensed insurers still operating in the state, collected after a failure rather than held in advance.
Protection is limited. Coverage caps are set by state law and differ between states and types of policy, and some products or claims are excluded. The funds are not backed by the federal government. This differs from the FDIC, which insures bank deposits from its own fund. The process usually begins when a court places the insurer in receivership or liquidation, and policyholders may wait a long time for full settlement.
AM Best
AM Best is a credit rating agency that specialises in the insurance industry. It was founded in 1899 and is based in New Jersey. Its best-known product is the Financial Strength Rating, an opinion on an insurer's ability to meet policyholder obligations. The scale runs from A++ and A+ (superior), through A and A- (excellent), B++ and B+ (good), and lower grades down to D (poor), with separate letters for companies under regulatory supervision, in liquidation or suspended. It also publishes issuer credit ratings for debt.
Buyers, brokers and lenders often require a minimum AM Best rating before placing business, and regulators and counterparties use ratings in their own rules. An assessment looks at balance-sheet strength, operating performance, business profile and enterprise risk management. As a credit rating agency, it sits beside general agencies such as Moody's, but a rating is an opinion, not a guarantee of solvency.
How the four terms fit together
The terms form a sequence of defence. Insurability tests decide what is offered, underwriting skill decides whether the offer is profitable, ratings tell the public how sound an insurer is, and guaranty funds provide limited help if the earlier layers fail.
Ref 1170000345