A hybrid mismatch arrangement is a cross-border structure that takes advantage of differences between two or more countries' tax rules in how they characterise a financial instrument, an entity or a payment. Because each country applies its own law, the same payment can be deductible in the payer's country yet not taxed as income in the payee's country, or deductible twice. The result is a reduction in total tax that neither country intended, even though each applies its own rules correctly.
Hybrid mismatches were a long-standing feature of international tax planning by multinational corporations. They became a focus of the OECD and G20 base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) project, whose Action 2 report, published in 2015, recommended co-ordinated rules to neutralise them. Those recommendations have since been adopted into law across the European Union, the United Kingdom, Australia and other countries. They sit alongside other anti-avoidance measures such as controlled foreign company rules.
How mismatches arise
There are two basic sources of hybridity. A hybrid financial instrument is treated as debt in one country and as equity in another. A typical example is a hybrid instrument such as a redeemable preferred share or a long-dated subordinated loan with profit-linked returns: the issuer's country treats payments as deductible interest expense, while the holder's country treats them as dividends that are exempt under a participation exemption.
A hybrid entity is treated as a taxable company in one country and as fiscally transparent, like a partnership or branch, in another. Elective classification regimes, such as the US entity classification ("check-the-box") rules, make such entities easy to create. A payment made by a hybrid entity may be deductible locally and also deductible to its owner, or a payment to a hybrid entity may be ignored in both countries. Mismatches can also arise from differences in how payments to or from a permanent establishment are recognised, and from dual-resident companies.
Types of outcome
The BEPS Action 2 report classifies mismatches by their tax effect:
- Deduction / no inclusion (D/NI). A payment is deductible for the payer but is not included in the ordinary income of the recipient.
- Double deduction (DD). The same expense is deductible in two jurisdictions, for example by a hybrid entity and its parent.
- Indirect deduction / no inclusion. Also called an imported mismatch: the effect of a hybrid arrangement between two countries is passed into a third country through an ordinary payment, such as a normal intra-group loan.
Neutralising rules
The OECD recommendations use a primary rule and a secondary, or defensive, rule so that the mismatch is eliminated whichever country acts. For a D/NI outcome, the primary response is to deny the deduction in the payer's jurisdiction; if that country has not adopted the rules, the payee's jurisdiction includes the payment in ordinary income. For a double deduction, the parent's jurisdiction denies the duplicate deduction, with the other country acting as a backstop. Imported mismatch rules deny deductions for payments that fund a hybrid arrangement elsewhere in the group. The rules generally apply only within groups and to structured arrangements, where the mismatch is priced into the terms or the arrangement is designed to produce it.
Separately, the report recommended changes to domestic law, for example denying dividend exemption for payments deductible to the payer, and changes to the OECD Model Tax Convention for transparent entities, later reflected in the 2017 Model and the Multilateral Instrument.
Implementation
In the European Union, the first Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD 1), adopted in 2016, contained hybrid rules for mismatches between member states. It was amended in 2017 by the directive commonly called ATAD 2, which extended the rules to arrangements involving non-EU countries and added imported mismatch and reverse hybrid rules. Member states generally had to apply the main ATAD 2 provisions from 1 January 2020, with the reverse hybrid rule following from 2022. The United Kingdom introduced its own anti-hybrid rules with effect from 1 January 2017. In the United States, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 added section 267A of the Internal Revenue Code, which denies deductions for certain interest and royalties paid in hybrid transactions or to hybrid entities.
Effects and criticism
The rules have largely ended the classic hybrid instrument and hybrid entity structures and affected capital instruments issued by banks and insurers, some of which received specific carve-outs. Critics point to their complexity: determining whether a mismatch exists requires knowledge of how a foreign country treats a payment, which taxpayers may not easily obtain, and the interaction of rules across countries can lead to double taxation where several countries act at once. Tax authorities and advisers also note significant compliance costs for ordinary intra-group financing. Hybrid rules now operate alongside the Pillar Two global minimum tax, which addresses low effective tax rates more broadly, and are a common subject of tax avoidance debate.