A government-to-person (G2P) payment is any payment made by a government or public agency to an individual. The main categories are social transfers, such as cash benefits, child grants and disability allowances; pensions; wages and salaries of public-sector employees; tax refunds; and one-off payments such as emergency relief or subsidies for fuel, food or farm inputs. G2P payments are among the largest and most regular flows of money in many economies.
The term is part of a classification of payment flows by sender and receiver used in financial inclusion and payments policy, alongside government-to-business (G2B), business-to-person (B2P), person-to-business (P2B) and person-to-person (P2P) payments. Payments in the other direction, such as taxes and fees, are person-to-government or business-to-government (B2G) flows.
Delivery methods
G2P payments can be made in cash, through vouchers or in-kind transfers, or electronically. Cash delivery traditionally involves officials or contracted agents distributing notes at pay points, post offices or bank branches on set days. It is costly and slow, exposes recipients to long journeys and queues, and creates opportunities for theft and for "ghost" beneficiaries who exist only on paper.
Electronic delivery credits funds to an account in the recipient's name. Options include:
- Bank accounts. Transfers to a standard or basic payment account, accessed by debit card, branch or ATM.
- Prepaid or limited-purpose cards. Cards loaded by the paying agency, sometimes usable only for withdrawals at specific points.
- Mobile money. Transfers to an e-money account, which recipients can spend digitally or withdraw through cash-out at a retail agent.
- Agent networks. Payments made through bank or mobile money agent banking outlets in places without branches.
Governments typically pay through a public payment system from a treasury single account, with one or more contracted banks or payment providers distributing funds to recipients. Whether recipients can choose their provider, and whether the account is a full transaction account or a single-purpose benefit card, are key design choices.
Digitising G2P payments and financial inclusion
Because almost every household receives some form of public payment, routing G2P flows into accounts is seen as one of the most powerful ways to expand financial inclusion. Data from the Global Findex Database show that receiving government payments is a common reason for opening a first account in many developing economies, and that a significant number of unbanked adults still receive such payments in cash.
A first account opened to receive a benefit can later be used to save, make digital payments and build a transaction history. That potential is realised only if the account is a genuine, low-cost, multi-purpose account and recipients can use it conveniently. Where benefit cards permit only a single withdrawal, most recipients simply take out the full amount in cash on payday, and little change in financial behaviour follows.
Efficiency, leakage and identification
Governments digitise G2P payments mainly to cut costs and reduce leakage. Electronic payments are easier to reconcile and audit, remove layers of intermediaries handling cash and make it harder to pay non-existent or duplicate recipients. Linking payment lists to a national ID system, sometimes a biometric identification system, is a common way to clean beneficiary rolls. Studies of reforms in India and elsewhere have found that electronic delivery can reduce leakage and delays, though results depend heavily on implementation.
India's Direct Benefit Transfer programme, begun in 2013, is a prominent example, combining bank accounts, national ID numbers and mobile phones to pay subsidies and benefits directly. Brazil's Bolsa Família conditional cash transfer, launched in 2003, has been paid through cards and accounts provided by the state bank Caixa Econômica Federal. During the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, several governments, including Togo with its Novissi programme, used mobile money to make emergency payments quickly to people outside existing registries.
Challenges and risks
Digitising G2P payments brings its own problems. Recipients in remote areas may live far from a working cash-out point, and agents may run out of cash on payday or charge unofficial fees. People who are elderly, have low literacy or lack phones and documents risk exclusion, as do those whose fingerprints fail to match. Contracts that give one provider exclusive rights can limit choice and keep fees high. Consumer protection, data privacy and accessible complaint channels are therefore part of good programme design, together with financial education for first-time account holders and oversight of payment providers by the relevant regulator.
The World Bank Group and the Better Than Cash Alliance, a partnership of governments, companies and international organisations founded in 2012, are among the bodies that publish guidance on moving G2P and other payments from cash to digital. G2P digitisation is also a frequent element of national financial inclusion strategies.
External links
Ref 1120000179