Group lending methodology is an approach to microfinance in which a lender makes loans to individuals who are organised into small groups, and uses the group to do much of the work that collateral, credit checks and loan officers do in ordinary banking. Members choose one another, meet regularly with a loan officer, and are expected to support, monitor and in many models guarantee each other's repayments. It became the signature method of the modern microcredit movement from the late 1970s onwards.
The method was designed for people with no assets to pledge, no credit history and small, irregular incomes, mostly in rural areas and often women. It is one of the main tools of financial inclusion and builds on much older informal arrangements such as rotating savings and credit associations (ROSCAs). Its main alternative is individual microcredit, and many institutions now use both.
Origins and the Grameen model
The best-known form was developed by the economist Muhammad Yunus in Bangladesh. In 1976 he began lending small sums to poor villagers near Chittagong, and the project grew into Grameen Bank, which became a specialised bank under a government ordinance in 1983. Yunus and Grameen Bank were jointly awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 2006.
In the classic Grameen design, borrowers formed groups of five people from similar backgrounds who were not close relatives. Several groups made up a centre that met weekly in the village with a loan officer. Loans were disbursed to two members first, and the others became eligible only if those two repaid on schedule. Repayments were small, equal and weekly, starting soon after disbursement. Members also saved, and the group's access to future, larger loans depended on everyone's record. Similar models spread through BRAC and other Bangladeshi organisations and to Latin America, Africa and Asia.
How group lending works
Although designs vary, most group programmes share a common set of features:
- Self-selection. Members form their own groups, which encourages people to join with those they trust to repay.
- Regular meetings. Groups meet weekly or fortnightly, where repayments are collected in public and new loans are discussed.
- Peer support or guarantee. In joint liability lending members must cover a defaulter's payments; in other models the pressure is social rather than contractual.
- Progressive lending. Small first loans grow with each cycle repaid on time, giving borrowers a strong incentive to keep their record clean.
- Compulsory or voluntary savings. Many programmes require small regular deposits, which build a buffer against shocks.
Loans are usually used for working capital in small trading, farming and craft activities, of the kind described under microenterprise loan. Meetings reduce the lender's cost per client, because one officer can serve many borrowers at once, a key driver of loan officer productivity.
Why the method works
Economists explain the success of group lending through the problems of asymmetric information in credit markets. A lender knows little about a poor borrower's character or business, but neighbours know a great deal. When groups form themselves, safer borrowers tend to group together, reducing adverse selection. Once loans are made, members watch how the money is used and press one another to repay, limiting moral hazard. The threat of losing access to credit for the whole group, together with social standing in the village, acts as a substitute for collateral. This line of analysis, developed in academic work from the 1990s, helped explain the high repayment rates that group programmes reported.
Variants
Several related methods are common. Solidarity groups, used widely in Latin America, are small groups of three to ten members, often with individual loans backed by a group guarantee. Village banking organises larger groups of perhaps twenty to fifty people who manage a fund on behalf of members, receiving an external loan from a sponsoring institution. In India, self-help groups of mostly women save together and borrow from banks under the bank linkage programme supported by the national development bank for agriculture. Purely savings-led models, set out under savings group methodology, use group structures without any external credit.
Criticism and changes
The method has been criticised on several grounds. Joint liability can damage relationships and force members to repay for others, and pressure at meetings has at times become coercive. Rigid weekly schedules suit traders but not farmers with seasonal income. Rapid commercial growth in some markets led to multiple borrowing and over-indebtedness, notably in the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh, where a crisis in 2010 led to a state ordinance restricting microfinance collections. Randomised evaluations in several countries, published in the 2010s, generally found that access to microcredit had modest average effects on business activity and little measurable effect on household poverty.
Lenders have adapted. Grameen Bank's revised model of the early 2000s, often called Grameen II, dropped formal joint liability and introduced more flexible loan terms. Many institutions now keep groups for delivery and meetings while assessing each borrower individually, and track outcomes through social performance management. Repayment discipline is still monitored closely through measures such as PAR30.