Fundamental indexing is a way of building a stock index in which each company's weight depends on the size of its business, measured by accounting figures such as revenue, cash flow, book value and dividends, rather than on the market value of its shares. A company that produces 2% of the total sales, cash flow and dividends of all eligible companies receives roughly a 2% weight, whatever its share price.
The approach was popularised by Robert Arnott and colleagues at Research Affiliates, who published the paper "Fundamental Indexation" in the Financial Analysts Journal in 2005; their indices carry the RAFI name. Fundamental indexing is one of the main alternatives to cap weighting, alongside the equal-weighted index and the factor-weighted index, and is commonly placed under the heading of smart beta or factor investing. Funds tracking fundamental indices are offered as ETFs and mutual funds.
How the weights are calculated
A typical fundamental index starts with a broad universe of listed companies, ranks them by a composite measure of size and selects the largest. For each company , the score on each fundamental measure is its share of the total for all selected companies, and the weight is the average of those shares:
- is the weight of company .
- is company 's value of fundamental measure , such as five-year average sales.
- is the number of measures used, often four.
For example, suppose a company accounts for 3% of the selected companies' total sales, 2% of cash flow, 2.5% of book value and 1.5% of dividends. Its weight is . In a cap-weighted index the same company might weigh 4% if investors value it highly, or 1% if they do not. Measures are usually averaged over several years to smooth out one-off results, and the index is rebalanced on a fixed schedule, often once a year.
The rationale
Supporters argue that cap weighting has a built-in flaw if prices contain noise. When a stock is overpriced, its market value and therefore its index weight are too high; when it is underpriced, its weight is too low. A cap-weighted index will then systematically hold too much of overvalued stocks and too little of undervalued ones. Weighting by fundamentals breaks the link between price and weight, so pricing errors no longer feed directly into the portfolio. This argument does not require markets to be inefficient in a predictable direction, only that prices deviate from fair value and later revert, a pattern related to mean reversion.
Supporters also point to back-tests showing that fundamental indices outperformed cap-weighted indices over long historical periods in many markets, with similar or modestly higher volatility. Rebalancing to fundamental weights works as a disciplined form of rebalancing that trims stocks whose prices have outrun their businesses.
Criticism
Critics argue that fundamental indexing is mainly a value strategy in disguise. Because weights ignore price, companies with low price-to-book ratios and high dividend yields receive more weight than in a cap-weighted index, giving a persistent tilt towards value stocks. Analyses that control for the value and size factors find that much of the historical outperformance is explained by those tilts. On that view, fundamental indexing is a transparent, low-cost way to obtain value exposure rather than a new source of return.
Other criticisms concern its status as an index. Unlike a cap-weighted index, a fundamental index cannot be held by all investors together, so it is an active bet relative to the market, consistent with the efficient market hypothesis only if value stocks earn a risk premium. Its returns can lag cap-weighted indices for long periods, notably when growth companies lead the market, as in the late 1990s and much of the 2010s.
In practice
Fundamental index funds typically charge more than the cheapest cap-weighted index funds but less than many actively managed funds. Their turnover is higher than that of a cap-weighted index, because weights must be reset at each rebalance, though usually lower than that of an equal-weighted index. Investors compare them using measures such as tracking error against the cap-weighted market, and some combine them with other approaches. The methodology has also been applied to bond indices, where weights can be based on measures such as an issuer's sales or a country's economic output instead of the amount of debt outstanding, avoiding the criticism that cap-weighted bond indices give the most weight to the most indebted borrowers.
Fundamental weighting differs from value investing by a fund manager in that its rules are fixed and published in advance. It is a form of rules-based active management that sits between traditional index tracking and stock picking.