A frontier market is the equity or debt market of a developing country that is smaller, less liquid and less open to foreign investors than the markets grouped as emerging markets. Frontier markets sit at an earlier stage of financial development. They have a functioning stock exchange and some foreign participation, but fewer listed companies, lower trading volumes and weaker market infrastructure. Investors treat them as a separate category within global portfolios.
The term was introduced in 1992 by Farida Khambata of the International Finance Corporation, the private-sector arm of the World Bank Group, to describe a set of smaller markets for which it had begun to publish data. Today the label is applied chiefly by index providers, whose classifications decide which countries appear in frontier, emerging and developed indices.
How markets are classified
There is no official list. Each index provider applies its own tests and reviews them every year. MSCI assesses three areas: the economic development of the country, the size and liquidity of its listed companies, and accessibility for foreign investors, which covers openness to foreign ownership, ease of moving capital, the efficiency of settlement and custody, and the stability of the rules. FTSE Russell and S&P Dow Jones Indices use similar criteria with different thresholds. A country can therefore be frontier in one provider's scheme and emerging in another's.
Countries that have appeared in frontier indices include Vietnam, Kazakhstan, Morocco, Romania, Kenya, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka. Classifications change. The United Arab Emirates and Qatar were moved by MSCI from frontier to emerging status in 2014 and Kuwait followed in 2020. Movement also goes the other way: Pakistan was promoted to emerging status in 2017 and returned to frontier status in 2021. A market that restricts the movement of foreign capital may be removed from the main indices altogether and treated as a standalone market.
Reclassification has practical effects. Promotion to an emerging benchmark index brings buying by the much larger pool of funds that track it, although the country then becomes a small part of a big index instead of a large part of a small one.
Characteristics
- Small size. Total market capitalization is low, and a handful of companies, often banks and telecommunications operators, make up most of each market.
- Low liquidity. Daily turnover is thin and the free float of many companies is narrow, so large orders take time to complete and move prices.
- Access limits. Foreign ownership caps, registration requirements and capital controls can restrict entry and, more seriously, exit.
- Weaker institutions. Disclosure standards, minority shareholder protection and the enforcement of contracts are less developed.
- Growth potential. Many frontier economies have young populations and low starting incomes, which is the basis of the investment case.
Risk and return
Frontier markets have historically shown a low correlation with developed markets and with one another, because their prices are driven mainly by local conditions. This has been presented as a source of diversification. The benefit is less reliable than the statistics suggest: thin trading makes measured volatility look lower than the true risk, and in global crises foreign investors have withdrawn from many frontier markets at once.
The main risks are the following.
- Currency. Devaluations and shortages of foreign exchange are frequent, and currency risk can outweigh local share price gains. In some cases investors have been unable to convert and repatriate sale proceeds for long periods.
- Political and policy risk. Changes of government, nationalisation, sudden tax or ownership rules and conflict are part of overall country risk.
- Liquidity. In a falling market there may be no buyers at any reasonable price, a form of liquidity risk.
- Costs. Brokerage, custody and taxes are higher than in larger markets.
Returns have varied widely between countries and periods, and no general conclusion can be drawn that frontier markets outperform.
Frontier debt
The term is also used for government debt. From the mid-2000s many low-income countries in Africa, Asia and Latin America issued bonds in international markets for the first time, typically as a dollar-denominated Eurobond. These issues are tracked by specialised bond indices. The risks became clear when several issuers, among them Zambia, Sri Lanka and Ghana, experienced a sovereign default between 2020 and 2022 and entered lengthy restructurings, often alongside a programme with the International Monetary Fund.
How investors gain exposure
Direct investment requires a local broker and custodian and sometimes a licence. Most investors use pooled vehicles: actively managed frontier funds, or an exchange-traded fund that tracks a frontier index. Some frontier companies can be bought through a global depositary receipt listed in London or elsewhere. Index-based products tend to be concentrated in a few countries and sectors, and fund managers may limit redemptions because the underlying shares cannot be sold quickly.