What is financial statement fraud?
Definition: The deliberate misstatement or omission of figures or disclosures in a company's financial reports to mislead investors, lenders, regulators or other users of the accounts.
Financial statement fraud, also called accounting fraud or "cooking the books", is the intentional falsification of a company's reported results, assets, liabilities or disclosures so that its financial position looks better, or occasionally worse, than it is. It is usually carried out by senior managers rather than junior staff, because only they can override controls and direct how transactions are recorded. Pressure to meet earnings forecasts, loan covenants or bonus targets, an opportunity created by weak oversight and a rationalisation such as "the numbers will recover" are the three elements of the fraud triangle that are often found together.
Research by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners has long found that it is the least frequent of the main categories of occupational fraud but the most costly per case. It differs from an honest error, and from an aggressive but permitted choice under GAAP or IFRS, by intent. An external audit gives reasonable, not absolute, assurance that statements are free of material misstatement, so a well-concealed fraud can pass through several annual reports filed on Form 10-K.
Main forms of manipulation
The schemes fall into four groups, and they are frequently combined.
- Overstated revenue. Sales are recorded too early, in the wrong amount or when they never occurred, which lifts profit and accounts receivable.
- Understated expenses. Ordinary operating costs are treated as long-lived assets, or recorded in a later period, so current profit rises.
- Hidden liabilities. Debts, guarantees or losses are moved to entities outside the consolidated accounts or to a related party and left out of the balance sheet.
- Overstated assets. Inventory, receivables or cash are reported at amounts that cannot be supported.
Channel Stuffing
Channel stuffing is the practice of shipping more product to distributors or retailers than they can sell, near the end of a reporting period, so that revenue is booked early. It is not unlawful in itself, because a company may offer sales incentives, but it becomes fraudulent when it relies on concealed rights of return, side letters that cancel or soften the obligation to pay, or promises to take stock back. Under revenue-recognition rules a sale is recorded only when control passes and the amount is reasonably collectible, so a sale that is likely to be reversed should not count.
Warning signs include a spike in shipments in the final days of a quarter, rising returns in the next quarter, receivables growing faster than sales and a lengthening days sales outstanding figure. The US Securities and Exchange Commission has brought cases against consumer-goods and pharmaceutical companies over the practice, including Sunbeam in 2001.
Fictitious Revenue
Fictitious revenue is the recording of sales that never took place. The sales may be made to invented customers, supported by forged invoices, shipping documents or confirmations, or booked against real customers who have not agreed to buy, sometimes under verbal side agreements. Because every sale creates a receivable, the false entries accumulate unless the "customers" later pay, so some schemes recycle cash through accomplices to make the receivables appear to be collected.
Indicators include receivables that are never paid or are repeatedly rolled forward, customers that cannot be traced, round-sum sales with unusual terms, and profit that is not matched by operating cash flow, which a high accrual ratio can reveal. Confirmation of balances directly with customers is a standard audit response.
Notable cases
Enron, which collapsed into bankruptcy in December 2001, used partnerships and special-purpose entities to keep debt and losses off its balance sheet, and its auditor Arthur Andersen ceased to practise after a criminal conviction. WorldCom disclosed in 2002 that it had treated line costs as capital expenditure, overstating earnings by billions of dollars. In Germany the payments group Wirecard filed for insolvency in June 2020 after its auditor could not verify that about 1.9 billion euros of cash it reported actually existed.
Detection and legal consequences
Common red flags are profit that is not matched by operating cash flow, unusual journal entries made at period end, transactions with related parties on unusual terms, frequent changes of auditor, aggressive revenue policies compared with peers, and a dominant executive who is not effectively challenged by the board or the audit committee. No single sign proves fraud, but a cluster of them normally prompts closer examination.
Detection draws on internal controls, analytical review, forensic accounting techniques such as Benford's law tests on digit patterns, and tips from a whistleblower. In the United States the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 requires chief executives and chief financial officers of listed companies to certify their financial reports, requires management to assess internal control over financial reporting, allows the recovery of bonuses after a restatement caused by misconduct, and created the PCAOB to oversee auditors. Knowingly certifying a false report is a crime, and securities fraud under 18 U.S.C. 1348 carries a maximum sentence of 25 years. The SEC brings civil actions and runs a whistleblower programme that pays awards from sanctions, and the Department of Justice prosecutes criminal cases.
External links
Ref 1010001602