The Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP) is a comprehensive review of a country's financial system carried out jointly by the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. It looks at how resilient banks, insurers, markets and financial infrastructure are to shocks, how well they are regulated and supervised, and how far the sector supports economic development and access to finance. Assessments are led by teams of staff and outside experts who work with the country's central bank, supervisors and ministry of finance.
The programme was launched in 1999, in the wake of the Asian and other emerging-market crises of the late 1990s, when the two institutions concluded that weaknesses in national financial sectors had been spotted too late. It is distinct from the IMF's annual country surveillance, though its findings feed into it, and from the AML/CFT mutual evaluations run by the FATF and its regional bodies.
Stability and development components
An FSAP has two strands. The stability assessment, led by the IMF, examines the sources of risk to financial stability, the quality of the policy framework and the capacity to manage a crisis. The development assessment, led by the World Bank in developing and emerging economies, looks at the depth and efficiency of the financial system, the legal and institutional framework, and the needs of underserved groups and sectors. In advanced economies the programme is usually carried out by the IMF alone and covers only the stability side.
The work typically covers several areas:
- Bank, insurance and sometimes household or corporate stress tests, run jointly with the authorities or by the team on supervisory data.
- Reviews of supervisory practice against international standards such as the Basel Core Principles, the IAIS core principles and the Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures.
- Analysis of macroprudential policy, the financial safety net, deposit insurance and bank resolution arrangements.
- On the development side, topics such as access to finance, credit reporting, payment systems, capital market development and housing or SME finance.
Mandatory assessments
For most countries an FSAP is voluntary and is requested by the authorities. In 2010 the IMF made financial stability assessments under the FSAP a mandatory part of its surveillance for members whose financial sectors are judged systemically important, initially 25 jurisdictions. Those members are expected to undergo the stability assessment about every five years. The list is set using a methodology based on the size and interconnectedness of each financial sector and has been revised and lengthened since its introduction. The programme was also reviewed after the 2007–2009 crisis to give more weight to systemic risk, cross-border linkages and the non-bank sector.
Outputs
The main IMF product is the Financial System Stability Assessment (FSSA), which is discussed by the IMF Executive Board together with the country's regular surveillance report. The World Bank's counterpart for developing countries is the Financial Sector Assessment (FSA). Both are usually accompanied by detailed technical notes on individual topics, such as stress testing, crisis management, insurance supervision or financial inclusion, and by assessments of observance of standards. Publication requires the country's consent, but most reports are now published. Their recommendations are often used by the authorities, donors and international bodies such as the Financial Stability Board to set reform priorities and plan technical assistance.
Financial inclusion and development
The development strand has made the FSAP an important source of diagnosis for financial inclusion policy in low- and middle-income countries. Development assessments may review the regulation of microfinance and digital financial services, the reach of banking and agent networks, the state of credit registries and collateral laws, and the role of state-owned or development banks. Their findings frequently inform a country's national financial inclusion strategy or a broader financial inclusion diagnostic.
Criticism and limitations
Commentators have noted that FSAPs before 2007 did not foresee the scale of the crisis in several advanced economies, partly because stress tests used too mild a scenario and partly because the assessments then gave less attention to interconnections and shadow banking. Other limits are structural: an FSAP is a snapshot taken every few years, it depends on data and cooperation supplied by the authorities, and its recommendations are not binding. The breadth of the exercise also means that resource-intensive assessments of large financial centres compete for staff with those of smaller countries.
External links
Ref 1270000018