An exchange for physical (EFP) is a privately negotiated transaction in which two parties simultaneously exchange a futures position for an equivalent position in the underlying physical commodity or cash instrument. One party buys the physical goods and sells futures, and the other sells the physical goods and buys futures. The two legs are agreed together, away from the exchange's trading system, and the futures leg is then reported to the exchange and cleared in the normal way.
EFPs are a long-standing exception to the rule that futures must be traded competitively on an exchange. They are used throughout commodity, energy, metal, currency and equity index markets to move between a hedge and the real asset in a single step. The trade is also known as exchange of futures for cash, against actuals or versus cash, and it belongs to a wider family that exchanges call exchange for related positions.
How an EFP works
An EFP has two linked components. The physical leg is a real transfer of ownership of the commodity or instrument from seller to buyer. The futures leg is a transfer of futures contracts in the opposite direction: the buyer of the physical is the seller of the futures, and the seller of the physical is the buyer of the futures. The quantities must be approximately equal.
The parties are free to set the price of the futures leg at any commercially reasonable level, and the price of the physical leg is fixed by reference to it. What they really negotiate is the difference between the two, the basis:
- is the price paid for the physical commodity.
- is the price at which the futures leg is recorded.
- is the agreed premium or discount of the physical to the futures, reflecting quality, location and timing.
Once agreed, the futures leg is submitted to the exchange by the parties' clearing firms and passes to the clearing house.
Worked example
A grain merchant holds 50,000 bushels of corn and has protected its value by selling ten futures contracts of 5,000 bushels each. A processor that will need corn has bought ten futures to fix its cost. The two agree an EFP. The merchant sells the processor the 50,000 bushels at 15 cents over the futures price, and the processor transfers its ten long futures to the merchant at $4.50 a bushel.
The cash price is dollars a bushel, so the processor pays dollars for the corn. The ten long contracts the merchant receives cancel its ten short contracts, and the processor's long position is gone. Both hedges are closed at the same price and at the same moment as the physical sale, so neither party is exposed to a move in the market between selling the goods and lifting the hedge.
Why EFPs are used
- Closing hedges without price risk. As in the example, a physical trade and the unwinding of both parties' hedging positions happen together.
- Pricing physical trades. Merchants agree the basis first and fix the flat price later through the futures leg, which separates the negotiation of the premium from the view on the market.
- Flexible delivery. The standard futures contract allows delivery only of set grades at a set delivery point. An EFP lets the parties deliver a different grade, at a different place and time, on terms that suit them.
- Opening positions. An EFP can create a new futures position against a new physical one, for example when a dealer sells a basket of shares and takes index futures in return.
- Trading outside market hours or in size. Large transactions can be arranged without moving the screen price, in a similar way to a block trade.
In precious metals, the quoted EFP is the price difference between gold futures in New York and metal for delivery in the London over-the-counter market. It is watched as a measure of the cost of moving between the two, and it has widened sharply at times when transporting metal became difficult or uncertain.
Rules and oversight
In the United States, the Commodity Exchange Act and the rules of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission permit EFPs only in accordance with the written rules of the designated contract market on which the futures are listed. Exchange rules require that the physical leg be a genuine transaction with a real transfer of ownership, that the physical product be the underlying of the futures or closely related to it, that quantities correspond, and that the two legs be between the same two parties on opposite sides.
Firms must keep documents proving the physical leg, such as contracts, invoices and delivery records, and produce them on request. Regulators have brought enforcement cases over EFPs that lacked a real physical leg and were used to disguise prearranged or wash trading in futures.
The same structure is used with other instruments in place of the physical commodity. In an exchange of futures for swaps, the related position is a swap, and in an exchange of options for options it is an over-the-counter option. The umbrella terms are exchange for related positions and exchange of derivatives for related positions. The older phrase exchange of futures for cash refers to the EFP itself.