The European Stability Mechanism (ESM) is the permanent crisis-resolution fund of the euro area. It lends to euro area countries that are cut off from market financing or face serious financing difficulties, in return for agreed policy conditions, and it raises the money by issuing bonds and bills. Based in Luxembourg, it is an intergovernmental institution created by a treaty among euro area countries, which entered into force on 27 September 2012; the ESM was inaugurated on 8 October 2012.
The ESM replaced two temporary bodies created in 2010, the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) and the European Financial Stabilisation Mechanism (EFSM), as the source of new euro area rescue loans. It is not an institution of the European Union, though it works closely with the European Commission and the ECB and, in several programmes, with the International Monetary Fund. Its maximum lending capacity is €500 billion.
Origins and legal basis
When the sovereign debt crisis began in Greece in 2010, the euro area had no permanent tool for lending to a member government, and the Treaties forbid the Union or member states from taking on another state's debts. The temporary facilities of 2010 were improvised. To place a permanent fund on firm legal ground, member states added a paragraph to Article 136 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union allowing euro area countries to set up a stability mechanism, with assistance subject to strict conditionality. In the Pringle case of November 2012, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that the ESM Treaty was compatible with EU law. Since 2013, a country can receive new ESM assistance only if it has ratified the Treaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance, which contains the fiscal compact.
Capital and governance
The ESM's shareholders are its member states. Its subscribed capital is roughly €700 billion, of which about €80 billion has been paid in and the rest can be called if needed. Each country's share follows a key based on its share of the ECB's capital. The paid-in capital and the callable capital behind it allow the ESM to borrow at low cost on the markets.
The Board of Governors consists of the finance ministers of the member states, the same people who meet as the Eurogroup, and takes the main decisions, such as granting assistance, by mutual agreement. An emergency procedure allows a decision with 85% of the votes when the Commission and the ECB conclude that delay would threaten the economic and financial sustainability of the euro area. A Board of Directors handles operational decisions, and a Managing Director runs the institution. Klaus Regling held the post from the start until 2022, when Pierre Gramegna succeeded him.
Lending instruments and programmes
The ESM can provide assistance in several forms:
- Programme loans. A full macroeconomic adjustment programme with loans paid out in instalments as reforms are delivered.
- Precautionary credit lines. Lines that a country with sound fundamentals can draw on if market access worsens.
- Loans for bank recapitalisation. Loans to a government to recapitalise its banks.
- Bond purchases. Purchases of a member's government bonds in the primary or secondary market.
Conditions are set out in a memorandum of understanding negotiated by the Commission, in liaison with the ECB and, where involved, the IMF, and progress is reviewed before each payment. The ESM has run programmes for Spain (2012 to 2013, loans to recapitalise banks), Cyprus (2013 to 2016) and Greece (2015 to 2018, the third Greek programme). In 2020 it offered Pandemic Crisis Support credit lines to cover health-related costs; no country drew on them. ESM conditionality also matters to monetary policy: a government must be under an ESM programme for its bonds to be bought under the ECB's Outright Monetary Transactions, announced in 2012.
Reform and the backstop
In early 2021 member states signed an agreement amending the ESM Treaty. Its main element would make the ESM the common backstop to the Single Resolution Fund, a credit line that the fund could draw on if its own resources were exhausted while resolving failing banks, so completing a key part of the banking union. The reform would also make precautionary credit lines easier to use and give the ESM a larger role in assessing debt sustainability and designing programmes. Every member except Italy ratified it; in December 2023 the Italian parliament voted against ratification, leaving the reform unable to enter into force. As of November 2026 Italy had still not ratified it.
Criticism
The ESM's programmes have been criticised for the social costs of the austerity and reforms attached to them, especially in Greece, and for the limited democratic oversight of an intergovernmental body whose decisions are taken by finance ministers. Supporters reply that the loans came at low interest rates and long maturities that no market would have offered, and that conditionality is the price of lending taxpayers' money. Others argue that the stigma of applying for help, shown by the unused pandemic credit lines, limits the fund's usefulness. Proposals to turn the ESM into a European Monetary Fund within EU law have not been adopted. The debate overlaps with the wider dispute over bail-outs and moral hazard.