The European Systemic Risk Board (ESRB) is the European Union body responsible for macroprudential oversight of the financial system as a whole. It identifies and assesses systemic risk, the danger that problems in one part of the financial system spread and disrupt it more widely, damaging the real economy, and it issues warnings and recommendations to prevent or reduce such risks. It was created by Regulation (EU) No 1092/2010, began work at the end of 2010 and held the first meeting of its General Board in January 2011.
The ESRB is hosted by the European Central Bank in Frankfurt, which provides its secretariat and much of its analysis, and it is chaired by the President of the ECB. It is one of the two pillars of the European System of Financial Supervision, alongside the three European Supervisory Authorities. Unlike them, it has no binding powers over financial firms. Its influence rests on analysis, peer pressure and the duty of addressees to respond to its recommendations. Among the ECB measures of stress across the whole financial system is the Composite Indicator of Systemic Stress (CISS), an index of euro-area financial stress on a scale from 0 to 1.
Origins and mandate
The 2008 crisis showed that supervision in Europe had focused on the soundness of individual institutions, while no authority was responsible for risks building up across the system, such as rising leverage, shared exposures to property or links between banks and funds. The de Larosière report of 2009 recommended a European body to fill this gap, and the ESRB was the result. Its mandate covers banks, insurers, asset managers, market infrastructures and other financial institutions in all 27 member states, not only the euro area. It is the main EU forum for macroprudential policy. A review in 2019 left its structure largely intact and confirmed that the ECB President would chair it.
Structure
The General Board takes the ESRB's decisions. Its voting members include the ECB President and Vice-President, the governors of the EU national central banks, a member of the European Commission, the chairs of the three supervisory authorities and the heads of the two advisory committees; senior representatives of national supervisors attend without a vote. A Steering Committee prepares the meetings, and the Secretariat runs daily work. The Advisory Scientific Committee brings in independent academic experts, and the Advisory Technical Committee brings together experts from central banks and supervisors. Working groups such as the European Systemic Cyber Group cover specialist topics.
Warnings, recommendations and act or explain
The ESRB can issue warnings and recommendations, either publicly or confidentially, to the Union as a whole, to member states, to the supervisory authorities, to national supervisors or to the Commission on EU legislation. Recommendations follow an act-or-explain mechanism: addressees must report what they have done or justify inaction, and the ESRB assesses compliance. Examples include:
- Foreign currency lending. Its first recommendation, in 2011, asked authorities to curb household foreign currency loans, mainly Swiss franc mortgages in central and eastern Europe.
- National macroprudential authorities. Also in 2011, it asked each member state to designate an authority with a clear macroprudential mandate.
- Capital buffers. In 2014 it issued guidance on setting the countercyclical capital buffer.
- Property markets. In 2016 and 2019 it sent warnings to several countries about medium-term vulnerabilities in residential real estate.
- Pandemic. In 2020 it recommended that financial institutions restrict dividend payments and share buy-backs during the COVID-19 crisis.
Monitoring and other tasks
The ESRB publishes a quarterly risk dashboard of indicators, an annual report and a regular monitor of non-bank financial intermediation. It designs the adverse scenarios used in EU-wide stress tests of banks and insurers run by the supervisory authorities. It also receives notifications of national macroprudential measures, such as a systemic risk buffer, assesses them and can recommend that other countries reciprocate so that the measure cannot be avoided by lending across borders. Its work extends to newer risks such as climate change and cyber threats.
Assessment
The ESRB is widely regarded as a useful forum for analysis and for coordinating national macroprudential policy. Critics point to its lack of binding powers, its reliance on consensus in a large board, and its dependence on national authorities to act, which can make its warnings slow and cautious. Some also question whether a body chaired by the ECB President can criticise monetary policy settings that may themselves feed financial risks. Its defenders reply that the act-or-explain process has led many countries to adopt measures they might otherwise have delayed.