Cyclical unemployment is the part of total unemployment that results from a fall in overall spending in the economy. When households and firms buy less, businesses cut production and lay off workers, and people who want jobs at prevailing wages cannot find them. This kind of unemployment rises in a recession and shrinks again as the economy recovers, following the business cycle. It is also called demand-deficient unemployment.
Economists set it apart from the kinds of unemployment that exist even in good times. Frictional unemployment arises because finding a suitable job takes time, and structural unemployment arises because workers' skills or locations do not match the jobs available. Together these make up the natural rate of unemployment. Cyclical unemployment is whatever lies above that rate.
Measuring it
Cyclical unemployment cannot be counted directly, since no survey can tell why a given person is out of work. It is estimated as a difference:
Here is the cyclical rate, is the measured unemployment rate and is the estimated natural rate. In the United States the measured rate is published monthly by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and estimates of the natural rate are produced by bodies such as the Congressional Budget Office. If the measured rate is 6.5 percent and the natural rate is put at 4.5 percent, cyclical unemployment is 2.0 percentage points. The figure can be negative in a boom, when unemployment falls below the natural rate.
Okun's law
The link between unemployment and lost output is summarized by a rule of thumb named after the economist Arthur Okun:
- is actual output and is potential output, the level the economy can sustain without rising inflation.
- The left side is the shortfall of output as a percentage of potential, the output gap.
- is the Okun coefficient, commonly taken as about 2 for the United States.
With cyclical unemployment of 2.0 points and a coefficient of 2, output is about percent below potential. The coefficient exceeds one because firms also cut hours and keep some idle staff when demand falls, and because some people stop looking for work and drop out of the count. The relationship is approximate and has varied across countries and periods.
Causes
The underlying cause is a drop in aggregate demand. Triggers include a financial crisis, a collapse in investment or housing, tighter credit, a fall in exports, or a deliberate tightening of policy to reduce inflation. In the account given by Keynesian economics, the shortfall persists because wages and prices do not fall quickly enough to restore employment. Wage contracts, minimum wages and the reluctance of firms to cut pay mean that adjustment comes through jobs instead. Other schools of thought place more weight on monetary causes, but agree that the unemployment is temporary and tied to the state of demand.
Policy responses
Because the cause is weak demand, the standard remedy is to raise it. Under monetary policy, a central bank lowers interest rates to encourage borrowing and spending. Under fiscal policy, the government spends more or taxes less. Some of this happens without any decision: in a downturn tax receipts fall and benefit payments rise, which cushions incomes.
Such measures do not reduce frictional or structural unemployment, which call for training, job-matching services and other supply-side policies. Pushing unemployment below the natural rate with demand alone is expected to raise inflation, the trade-off described by the Phillips curve. The goal of demand management is therefore full employment, meaning zero cyclical unemployment and not zero unemployment.
Limits of the concept
The natural rate is not observable and estimates of it are revised, sometimes substantially, so the size of cyclical unemployment at any moment is uncertain. Policymakers have at times misjudged it in both directions.
The boundary between cyclical and structural unemployment is also not fixed. People who are out of work for a long time lose skills and contacts and may become hard to employ even when demand returns. A deep recession can therefore raise the natural rate itself, an effect known as hysteresis. For financial markets, the distinction matters because it shapes expectations of central bank action: a rise in unemployment judged to be cyclical points toward lower interest rates, while one judged structural does not.