A credit adjustment spread (CAS) is an additional margin added to a risk-free reference rate when a contract moves off LIBOR or another interbank offered rate, so that the new rate is roughly worth the same as the old one. It was a central part of the transition away from LIBOR, which ended for most currencies at the end of 2021 and for the remaining US dollar panel settings on 30 June 2023.
The spread exists because the two kinds of benchmark measure different things. An interbank offered rate is a term rate for unsecured lending to banks, so it contains a bank credit premium and a term premium. Overnight risk-free rates such as SOFR and SONIA contain almost neither. Without an adjustment, swapping one for the other would have handed a windfall to borrowers and a loss to lenders and investors across trillions of dollars of contracts.
Why a spread is needed
LIBOR was historically above the comparable overnight rate, and the gap widened in periods of bank stress, most sharply in 2008. Replacing LIBOR with a compounded overnight rate alone would therefore have lowered the interest payable on a legacy loan, bond or swap overnight. The CAS is meant to close that gap on average, not on any particular day. It is a value transfer correction, not a measure of the borrower's own credit spread, which stays in the separate loan margin.
Two broad ways of setting the spread were debated by industry working groups from around 2018: looking backwards at the historical relationship between the rates, or looking forwards at market prices that showed where the relationship was expected to go.
ISDA Historical Median Approach
The ISDA historical median approach fixes the spread as the median of the daily differences between an IBOR tenor and the compounded RFR over the matching period, measured across the five years before a trigger event. The International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) chose it after consultations in 2018 and 2019, and built it into its fallbacks for derivatives, including the 2020 IBOR Fallbacks Protocol. A median was preferred to a mean because it is less affected by short spikes such as the 2008 crisis.
The spreads were locked on 5 March 2021, when the Financial Conduct Authority announced the dates on which each LIBOR setting would cease or stop being representative. That announcement counted as the trigger for fixing the adjustment, even though the switch itself came later. From that date the spread for each currency and tenor was a fixed number; for three-month US dollar LIBOR it was about 0.26 percentage points. Many loan markets adopted the same values so that a loan and its hedge would move together.
Forward Spread Approach
The forward spread approach derives the adjustment from market prices instead of history. A basis swap that exchanges LIBOR for a compounded RFR shows the spread the market expects between the two over each future period. Taking that spread at the time of transition gives an adjustment reflecting current conditions and the expected path of bank credit premia, and in principle it avoids any value transfer on the day of the switch.
Its weaknesses decided the debate. Basis swap markets were thin in some currencies and tenors, prices could be moved by the transition itself, and different firms could observe different prices on the same day. The historical median approach was simpler, transparent and impossible to manipulate once fixed, so it became the market standard. Some early bilateral loans that converted to an RFR before March 2021 used forward-looking or negotiated spreads, and some new RFR loans dropped the CAS entirely and priced the full difference into the margin.
Using the spread in loans
A loan referencing a compounded RFR plus a CAS builds its interest rate in layers:
- is the RFR for the interest period, usually compounded in arrears or a term rate.
- is the credit adjustment spread for the replaced tenor.
- is the lender's margin for the borrower's credit risk.
For example, a loan that formerly paid three-month US dollar LIBOR plus 2.00 per cent could move to compounded SOFR plus a CAS of 0.26161 per cent plus the same 2.00 per cent margin. If compounded SOFR for a period is 4.30 per cent, the all-in rate is per cent. The mechanics of selecting and applying the replacement are set out in fallback rate determination and in the benchmark fallback provisions of the loan agreement.
Limits and criticism
- Static spread. A fixed CAS cannot rise in a future stress, so lenders no longer receive extra compensation when bank funding costs jump, which was one of LIBOR's features.
- Average, not exact. Because it is a five-year median, the spread overstated or understated the gap on any given date, which some borrowers and lenders contested during LIBOR transition of legacy contracts.
- Fading relevance. New loans arranged after the transition are usually priced directly off the RFR, and the separate CAS line has gradually disappeared from many term sheets.
External links
Ref 1100001627