A credit event is a defined occurrence affecting a borrower, called the reference entity, that obliges the seller of a credit default swap to compensate the buyer of protection. The concept also appears in other credit derivatives, such as credit-linked notes and index tranches, where it marks the point at which losses are passed from one party to another.
Credit events are defined contractually rather than by law. Almost all trades incorporate the ISDA Credit Derivatives Definitions published by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA), most recently the 2014 edition, which list the event types and the tests each must meet. A credit event is related to, but narrower and more precise than, the everyday idea of default: a company can be in severe financial trouble without any credit event having occurred under the contract.
Standard types of credit event
A trade confirmation states which events apply to each reference entity. The main types are:
- Bankruptcy. Insolvency, a winding-up, an assignment for the benefit of creditors or similar proceedings affecting the reference entity.
- Failure to pay. Non-payment of an obligation above a minimum amount once any grace period has run out.
- Restructuring. A binding change to the terms of debt, such as a cut in principal or interest or a postponement of payment, that results from a deterioration in creditworthiness.
- Obligation acceleration and obligation default. Debt becoming due early, or capable of being declared due, because of a default.
- Repudiation or moratorium. An authorised officer or government rejecting the debt or declaring a halt to payments, followed by an actual failure to pay or restructuring.
The 2014 Definitions also added governmental intervention, aimed at banks and other financial reference entities whose debt is written down or converted by a resolution authority.
Corporate and sovereign contracts
The applicable events depend on the type of reference entity and the regional market convention. Standard North American corporate contracts usually apply bankruptcy and failure to pay only, while European and some other corporate contracts also include restructuring, with rules that limit which bonds can be delivered after a restructuring. Sovereign contracts drop bankruptcy, because states do not go through insolvency proceedings, and rely on failure to pay, restructuring and repudiation or moratorium. The best-known sovereign case is Greece in March 2012, when the use of collective action clauses to impose losses on private bondholders was ruled a restructuring credit event and outstanding contracts were settled through an auction.
Who decides that a credit event has occurred
Since 2009, questions about credit events have been decided by regional Credit Derivatives Determinations Committees made up of dealer and investor members. Any eligible market participant can ask a committee whether an event has occurred; the committee rules on the question, sets the event date and decides whether an auction will be held. Decisions are binding on all trades that incorporate the standard definitions, which avoids thousands of separate bilateral disputes. A lookback period, generally 60 days, means that protection bought shortly after an event can still be triggered by it.
The counterparties can also act bilaterally by serving a credit event notice, supported by publicly available information, where no committee decision applies.
Settlement after a credit event
Historically, the buyer delivered a defaulted bond to the seller in exchange for its face value, known as physical settlement. Because outstanding CDS can exceed the bonds available, the market moved to auction-based cash settlement, made standard by the CDS protocols of 2009. The auction sets a final price for the deliverable obligations, and the protection seller pays the loss implied by that price:
- is the notional amount of the contract.
- is the auction final price, quoted as a percentage of face value.
For a contract with a notional amount of $10,000,000 and a final price of 35, the payout is , or $6.5 million, less any accrued premium owed by the buyer. The protection buyer thus recovers the gap between par and the market's estimate of recovery.
Criticism and limitations
Because the definitions are technical, the outcome of a distressed situation can hinge on drafting details. Disputes have arisen over whether a debt exchange was voluntary, which bonds count as deliverable, and whether engineered or "manufactured" events allowed some holders to trigger or avoid a payout. ISDA has amended the definitions several times in response. Critics also point out that committee members trade the same contracts they rule on, although published procedures and external review are intended to manage that conflict.
External links
Ref 1100001477