The combined buffer requirement (CBR) is the total amount of Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital that a bank in the European Union must hold on top of its minimum capital requirements. It is the sum of several capital buffers: the capital conservation buffer, the bank's own countercyclical buffer, the systemic risk buffer and, for systemically important banks, a buffer for global or other systemic importance. Each is expressed as a percentage of the bank's total risk exposure amount, its risk-weighted assets (RWA).
The buffers come from the Basel III reforms that followed the global financial crisis, and in the EU they are set out in the Capital Requirements Directive (CRD), which defines the CBR in Article 128. Unlike minimum requirements, buffers are meant to be used: a bank may fall into its buffer during stress without losing its licence. Doing so, however, triggers automatic limits on dividends, bonuses and coupon payments, which is why banks usually keep a margin of capital above the CBR.
Components of the combined buffer
The CBR brings together up to four layers:
- Capital conservation buffer. A fixed 2.5% of risk-weighted assets that applies to every bank, set directly in law (capital conservation buffer).
- Institution-specific countercyclical buffer. A weighted average of the countercyclical capital buffer rates set in each country where the bank has credit exposures. National authorities raise the rate when credit grows quickly and can cut it to zero in a downturn.
- Systemic risk buffer. A tool that national authorities can apply to all banks, a group of banks or particular exposures, such as residential mortgages, to address structural risks (systemic risk buffer).
- Systemic importance buffers. Banks identified as global systemically important institutions hold a G-SII buffer, set by bucket; other systemically important institutions hold an O-SII buffer. Where a bank is both, the higher of the two applies.
Since the CRD V amendments of 2019, the systemic risk buffer is added on top of the G-SII or O-SII buffer rather than competing with it.
Calculation and worked example
For a bank subject to all four layers, the requirement is:
Here is the capital conservation buffer rate, the bank's own countercyclical buffer rate, the systemic risk buffer rate and the last term the higher of its two systemic importance buffer rates, all as percentages of risk-weighted assets.
Take a bank with risk-weighted assets of 50 billion euros, a conservation buffer of 2.5%, a countercyclical rate of 1.0%, a systemic risk buffer of 0.5%, an O-SII buffer of 1.0% and no G-SII buffer. Its CBR is , or 2.5 billion euros of CET1. That sits above its Pillar 1 CET1 minimum of 4.5% and above the CET1 part of its Pillar 2 capital requirement, which must be at least 56.25% of the Pillar 2 add-on. With a Pillar 2 requirement of 2.0%, the CET1 part is 1.125%, so the bank's total CET1 requirement including buffers is , or about 5.3 billion euros. Pillar 2 guidance (P2G), where set, is expected to be held above this stack but is not part of the CBR.
Breaching the buffer
A bank that does not meet its CBR is not in breach of its minimum requirements, but restrictions apply at once. Under Article 141 of the CRD it must calculate its maximum distributable amount (MDA), a cap on the profits it may pay out, and tell its supervisor. The cap applies to dividends, share buybacks, variable pay such as bonuses, and coupons on Additional Tier 1 (AT1) capital. The MDA is a share of recent profits that falls to zero the deeper the bank is in its buffer. The bank must also submit a capital conservation plan explaining how it will restore its capital.
Because AT1 coupons may be cut, the distance between a bank's CET1 ratio and its MDA trigger is watched closely by investors. Similar buffer-based limits apply to the leverage ratio buffer for G-SIIs and, under the resolution framework, to banks that fall short of the buffer stacked on top of their minimum requirement for own funds and eligible liabilities (MREL).
Who sets the buffers and how they are used
Most buffer rates are set by national designated authorities, which also identify O-SIIs, while the list of global systemically important banks is coordinated internationally. In the banking union, the ECB can apply higher buffer rates than national authorities under the Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM) rules, but it cannot lower them. The buffers form part of macroprudential policy, the effort to make the banking system as a whole more resilient.
The test of usability came in March 2020, when the ECB said banks could temporarily operate below the capital conservation buffer and their Pillar 2 guidance, and many authorities cut countercyclical rates. Studies afterwards found that banks were reluctant to dip into buffers, fearing MDA limits and market stigma. That led to debate about shifting more capital into releasable buffers, and several countries have since set a positive countercyclical rate even when risks are not elevated.