A circular economy is a model of production and consumption in which goods and materials are kept in use for as long as possible and waste is designed out. Products are made to last, to be repaired and to be taken apart, and at the end of their life the materials are recovered and fed back into production. The aim is to separate economic activity from the consumption of finite resources.
The idea is usually set against the linear model of take, make and dispose, in which raw materials are extracted, turned into goods and discarded after use. It is promoted by governments, companies and non-profit bodies as a response to resource depletion, pollution and climate change, and it has become a theme in sustainable investing and in environmental regulation, particularly in the European Union.
Principles
The concept draws on earlier schools of thought, including industrial ecology and cradle-to-cradle design. The most widely cited formulation, from the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, a charity set up in 2010, rests on three principles:
- Eliminate waste and pollution. Waste is treated as a design flaw. Products, packaging and processes are planned so that harmful by-products do not arise.
- Circulate products and materials. Goods and components are kept at their highest value through maintenance, reuse, refurbishment and remanufacturing, with recycling as the last resort.
- Regenerate nature. Biological materials are returned safely to the soil, and energy comes from renewable energy sources.
A distinction is drawn between technical materials, such as metals and plastics, which are meant to circulate in closed loops, and biological materials, which can be composted or digested.
Business models
Companies apply the idea through a handful of recurring models. In product-as-a-service arrangements the maker keeps ownership and the customer pays for use, through a lease or subscription, which gives the maker a reason to build durable goods and to recover them. Resale and sharing platforms extend the life of clothing, vehicles and equipment. Remanufacturing restores used parts, such as engines and photocopiers, to original specification. Recycling businesses turn scrap into secondary raw materials, and design changes cut the amount of material used in the first place.
These models change the pattern of cash flows. Selling a service spreads revenue over time and leaves assets on the provider's balance sheet, so they need more working capital and different financing from one-off sales. They can also reduce exposure to volatile commodity prices and to disruption in a long supply chain, because part of the material input comes from the company's own returned products.
Policy and regulation
The European Union has gone furthest in turning the concept into law. Its circular economy action plans of 2015 and 2020 led to rules on product design, repairability, packaging, batteries and waste. The transition to a circular economy is one of the six environmental objectives of the EU taxonomy, the classification that defines which activities may be described as environmentally sustainable in financial products. China has had circular economy legislation since 2009, and many other countries use extended producer responsibility schemes that make manufacturers pay for the collection and treatment of their products.
In economic terms such rules aim to correct an externality: the cost of waste and pollution falls on society at large and not on the producer, so the market price of a product understates its true cost.
Role in finance and investing
Circular economy criteria appear in several parts of the capital markets. Projects such as recycling plants and reuse systems are an eligible category for green bonds, and some issuers of sustainability-linked bonds tie the interest rate to targets for recycled content or waste reduction. Asset managers run thematic equity funds that hold companies in waste management, recycling technology, rental and repair. In ESG investing more broadly, data providers score companies on material use, waste and product design, and analysts treat poor performance as a source of regulatory and cost risk.
Banks and development institutions also offer dedicated lending, and the theme is linked to several of the Sustainable Development Goals, notably the goal on responsible consumption and production. Circular measures are often counted toward corporate targets for a lower carbon footprint, since making goods from recovered material usually takes less energy than making them from virgin material.
Criticism and limitations
Critics point out that full circularity is physically impossible. Materials degrade each time they are processed, recycling itself uses energy, and some products disperse their materials in use. Economists also note a rebound effect: if reuse makes goods cheaper, total consumption may rise and offset the saving.
Measurement is a further difficulty. There is no single agreed metric for how circular a company or product is, which makes claims hard to compare and leaves room for exaggerated marketing. For investors, thematic funds can end up concentrated in a few industries, and the profitability of recycling depends heavily on the price of the virgin materials with which recovered materials compete.