Broker-dealer practices and violations is the family of conduct by securities firms and their registered staff that US regulators treat as improper, or that has been controversial enough to prompt rule changes. A broker-dealer buys and sells securities for customers and for its own account, so it has several points at which its interests can conflict with those of clients and of the market.
The three practices below show different sides of that risk. Backing away is a failure to honour a published quote. Selling away is a representative selling products behind the firm’s back. Flash trading was a way of showing orders early to a select few. Oversight comes mainly from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), which can fine firms, suspend them and bar individuals from the industry.
Backing Away
Backing away occurs when a market maker publishes a bid or offer and then refuses to trade at that price, or at that size, when another broker tries to hit it. It breaks the idea that a displayed quotation is a commitment. The main rule is the firm quote rule, now Rule 602 of Regulation NMS, which requires an exchange member or over-the-counter market maker to honour its published quote for the stated size unless a limited exception applies. The practice became notorious during the October 1987 crash, when some market makers stopped answering calls.
Penalties for backing away include censure, fines and trading restrictions imposed by FINRA or the SEC. It differs from trading ahead, in which a firm trades for itself before filling a customer order, which is treated as a separate violation.
Selling Away
Selling away is the sale of securities by a registered representative outside the knowledge and supervision of the firm that employs him or her. Under FINRA Rule 3280 on private securities transactions, a representative must give the firm written notice before taking part in such a deal and, if the firm approves it, the firm must supervise it as if it were its own business. FINRA has proposed combining this rule with others on outside activities. Typical cases involve promissory notes or private placements sold to clients, some of which later turn out to be a Ponzi scheme.
Sanctions include suspensions, permanent bars and fines, and firms may be held liable for failing to supervise. Warning signs for investors include requests to pay a person rather than the firm, and products that do not appear on statements. A representative’s history can be checked on BrokerCheck.
Flash Trading
Flash trading was a practice in which an exchange briefly showed certain customer orders, for a fraction of a second, to a limited set of subscribers before routing them elsewhere. Participants could then take the other side. Supporters said it improved the chance of a fill at the best price; critics said it gave a few firms early sight of orders and was unfair to other investors, and linked it to the speed advantages of High Frequency Trading (HFT).
The controversy peaked in 2009. Several exchanges dropped flash orders after public criticism, and in September 2009 the SEC proposed banning them, although the proposal was never finalised. The term is also sometimes confused with the later debate over fast traders described in the book Flash Boys, and with the Flash Crash of 2010, which is a separate event.
How the practices compare
| Practice | Who acts | Main rule | Core concern |
|---|---|---|---|
| Backing away | Market maker | Rule 602, Regulation NMS | Quotes not honoured |
| Selling away | Registered representative | FINRA Rule 3280 | Unsupervised sales to clients |
| Flash trading | Exchange | Proposed SEC ban, not adopted | Unequal access to order information |
External links
Ref 1210000785