Home / Wiki / B / Best-Efforts Underwriting

Best-Efforts Underwriting

Investment and Capital MarketsUpdated 16 Nov 2026

Best-efforts underwriting is an arrangement for selling new securities in which the underwriter acts as the agent of the issuer and promises only to use its best efforts to find buyers. The underwriter does not purchase the securities for its own account and is not liable for any that remain unsold. The issuer therefore carries the risk that the offering raises less money than planned, or none at all.

The arrangement is the main alternative to a firm commitment, in which an underwriting syndicate buys the whole issue from the company and resells it, taking the risk of unsold stock. Best efforts is typical of small or speculative issues, including some smaller offerings of the initial public offering type, direct participation programs and offerings by young companies that no bank is willing to buy outright.

01

How the arrangement works

The issuer and the underwriter, normally an investment bank or a smaller broker-dealer, sign an agency agreement. The underwriter markets the securities to its customers during a stated offering period at the price set in the prospectus, and may bring in other dealers as a selling group. For each security sold it earns a commission, sometimes with warrants or reimbursement of expenses. Securities that find no buyer stay with the issuer and are simply not issued.

Because the underwriter never owns the securities, it puts little of its own capital at risk. The legal duties that apply to underwriting in general still hold. In a registered US offering the underwriter is expected to investigate the issuer with reasonable care and can be liable for material misstatements in the offering documents.

02

Forms of best-efforts offering

  • Straight best efforts. Every sale stands. The issuer keeps whatever amount is raised, however small.
  • All-or-none. In all-or-none underwriting the offering is cancelled and investors are repaid unless the entire issue is sold by a set date.
  • Minimum-maximum. A "mini-max" offering sets a floor and a ceiling. Sales become final once the minimum is reached, and selling may continue up to the maximum.

The contingent forms protect investors from being left holding securities in a company that has raised too little to carry out its plans.

03

Escrow and investor protection

In the United States, contingent offerings are governed by two rules of the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Rule 10b-9 makes it a deceptive practice to describe an offering as all-or-none, or as subject to a minimum, unless investors are promptly refunded if the condition is not met by the stated date. Rule 15c2-4 requires investor payments to be passed promptly to a separate bank account or to an independent escrow agent until the contingency is satisfied.

Regulators have brought cases where a minimum was reached only through purchases by the issuer's insiders or by the underwriter itself, without disclosure, since such purchases defeat the purpose of the condition. The usual steps of a public offering, including securities registration and the cooling-off period before sales begin, apply in the same way as to a firm commitment deal.

04

Comparison with firm commitment

The two methods divide risk differently. In a firm commitment the issuer knows on the pricing date how much it will receive, and the underwriters profit from the spread between the price they pay and the public offering price. They also usually support the issue in the aftermarket and may hold a greenshoe option to cover excess demand. In a best-efforts deal the proceeds are uncertain until the offering closes, fees are a commission on what is sold, and aftermarket support is usually limited.

The choice also carries information. A bank that is willing to buy an issue outright signals confidence in its ability to place it, so investors tend to read a best-efforts structure as a sign that the issue is harder to sell. Academic studies of US offerings have found that best-efforts issues are, on average, smaller and riskier, and that a meaningful share of them fail to reach their minimum and are withdrawn.

05

Risks and criticism

For the issuer, the main risk is a shortfall: the costs of preparing the offering are incurred whether or not the money is raised. For investors, the risks are those of small, thinly traded issues, such as small-cap stocks and unlisted programs, where the price after the offering may be hard to establish. An offering sold on a straight best-efforts basis can leave early investors committed to an underfunded company. Similar agency arrangements are used in a private placement, where a placement agent seeks buyers without committing its own capital.

Last updated 16 Nov 2026