The Automated Customer Account Transfer Service (ACATS) is the system used in the United States to move a customer's brokerage account, with its securities and cash, from one firm to another. It is operated by the National Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC), a subsidiary of the Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation. The service lets positions move as they are, without being sold at the old firm and bought again at the new one.
ACATS has run since the 1980s and replaced a slow exchange of paper forms and certificates between firms. Almost every broker-dealer that holds customer accounts takes part, along with many banks and trust companies. The service standardizes the messages and deadlines for a transfer, and industry rules oblige firms to use it and to act within set time limits when a customer asks to move.
How a transfer works
The customer starts the process at the new firm, known as the receiving firm, by opening an account and signing a transfer form. The customer does not need to contact the old firm. The steps are then:
- Request. The receiving firm enters the transfer into ACATS, identifying the account at the delivering firm.
- Validation. The delivering firm has one business day to confirm the request or to reject it for a stated reason, such as a name or tax identification number that does not match.
- Review. The delivering firm sends a list of the assets in the account. The receiving firm examines it and may decline assets it cannot hold.
- Settlement. Positions are moved between the two firms' accounts at the depository and cash is paid through the clearing corporation.
A standard transfer of a whole account usually completes within about a week. The delivering firm freezes the account once the request is validated, cancelling open orders, and it may charge a transfer-out fee.
Full and partial transfers
A full transfer moves everything and closes the old account. A partial transfer moves only the positions or cash the customer names and leaves the old account open. Dividends, interest and other credits that arrive at the old firm after a full transfer are forwarded automatically for a period afterwards, as residual credits.
Transfers must be between accounts of the same type and ownership. An individual retirement account, for example a Roth IRA, goes to the same kind of account, and a joint account to a joint account with the same owners. A margin account can be moved with its loan balance, provided the account meets the receiving firm's margin requirements; otherwise the customer must pay down the debit first or accept a cash account.
Assets that do not transfer
Listed shares, exchange-traded funds, bonds, listed options and most holdings of a mutual fund move without difficulty. Several kinds of asset do not:
- Proprietary products. Funds and structured products available only at the delivering firm must be sold or left behind.
- Fractional shares. A fractional share is normally sold and the cash transferred, since firms do not deliver fractions to one another.
- Insurance and private assets. An annuity contract, a limited partnership interest or unlisted shares need separate paperwork with the issuer or its transfer agent.
- Positions under restriction. Options about to expire, securities in the middle of a corporate action and unsettled trades can delay or block the move.
ACATS handles transfers between brokerage firms. Shares held directly on an issuer's register move to a broker through the Direct Registration System, and newly issued or restricted shares often move by Deposit/Withdrawal at Custodian. Transfers involving Canadian dealers use Account Transfer Online Notification. Where an introducing firm holds its customers' accounts at a carrying broker, that broker is the party connected to the system.
Common problems
Most delays come from mismatched details between the two accounts, from assets the receiving firm will not accept, or from a margin shortfall. The original cost basis of each position is sent through a separate service some days after the assets and should be checked when it arrives, because errors affect later tax reporting.
The convenience of the system has also been abused. In ACATS fraud, a criminal uses stolen personal details to open an account in the victim's name at another firm and requests a transfer of the victim's assets, a form of account takeover. Regulators have asked firms to verify new accounts carefully and to alert customers when an outgoing transfer is requested.