The Asset Purchase Programme (APP) is the umbrella name for the European Central Bank's main quantitative easing programmes, under which the Eurosystem bought large amounts of bonds and other securities issued in the euro area. Launched in stages from 2014, it was meant to lift inflation back towards the ECB's price stability aim at a time when the key interest rates were already close to their effective lower bound and could not usefully be cut much further. At their peak in 2022, the Eurosystem's holdings under the programme were worth more than €3 trillion.
The APP has four parts, described below. It is separate from the pandemic emergency purchase programme (PEPP) started in March 2020 and from the earlier Securities Markets Programme of 2010. Decisions on the APP are taken by the ECB's Governing Council, while most purchases are carried out in a decentralised way by the national central banks.
Components of the programme
- Third covered bond purchase programme (CBPP3). Started in October 2014, it bought euro-denominated covered bonds issued by euro-area banks, following two smaller covered bond purchase programmes in 2009 and 2011.
- Asset-backed securities purchase programme. The ABSPP, started in November 2014, bought senior and guaranteed mezzanine tranches of securitisations backed mainly by loans to households and firms.
- Public sector purchase programme. The PSPP, started in March 2015, bought bonds of euro-area central governments, public agencies, regional and local governments and European supranational institutions. It was by far the largest part.
- Corporate sector purchase programme. The CSPP, started in June 2016, bought investment-grade euro bonds issued by non-bank companies established in the euro area.
How purchases were scaled up and wound down
The ECB announced the expanded programme on 22 January 2015, committing to combined monthly purchases of €60 billion. The pace rose to €80 billion from April 2016 to March 2017, then fell to €60 billion for the rest of 2017, €30 billion from January to September 2018 and €15 billion in the last quarter of 2018. Net purchases stopped at the end of 2018, but the principal of maturing bonds was reinvested so that holdings stayed broadly stable.
With inflation still below the aim, net purchases resumed in November 2019 at €20 billion a month, and in March 2020 the Governing Council added a temporary envelope of €120 billion as the pandemic began. As inflation rose sharply, net purchases ended on 1 July 2022, shortly before the first increase in the deposit facility rate since 2011. Reinvestments were reduced from March 2023 and stopped entirely from July 2023, so holdings have since fallen as bonds mature, a passive form of quantitative tightening.
How the programme was meant to work
The ECB pointed to several channels. Buying bonds raised their prices and lowered their yields, flattening the yield curve and cutting long-term borrowing costs for governments, firms and households. Investors who sold bonds to the Eurosystem moved into other assets, lifting their prices and easing financing conditions more widely, a process known as portfolio rebalancing. The purchases also created large amounts of central bank reserves and supported forward guidance by signalling that policy rates would stay low for a long time. Together with negative rates and targeted longer-term refinancing operations, the APP formed the core of the ECB's toolkit in the low-inflation years of the late 2010s.
Rules and safeguards
To respect the EU Treaty ban on monetary financing of governments, the Eurosystem bought public sector bonds only in the secondary market, never directly from issuers, and capped the share of any single issue and any single issuer it would hold, generally at one third. Government bond purchases were allocated across countries broadly in line with the national central banks' shares in the ECB's capital key, rather than according to need, and most of the risk of losses on national government bonds stayed with the relevant national central bank. Bonds had to meet eligibility and credit quality rules, and at first the Eurosystem did not buy bonds yielding less than the deposit facility rate, a restriction relaxed from 2017.
Legal challenges
The PSPP was challenged before the German courts. In the Weiss case, the German Federal Constitutional Court asked the Court of Justice of the European Union whether the programme breached the ban on monetary financing or went beyond the ECB's monetary policy mandate. In its judgment of 11 December 2018, the Court of Justice found that it did neither. On 5 May 2020, however, the German court ruled that the ECB had not shown the programme to be proportionate and that the Court of Justice's ruling on that point exceeded its powers. The Governing Council then made documents on its proportionality assessment available through the Bundesbank, and the German court later rejected applications to enforce its ruling. The European Commission opened infringement proceedings against Germany over the judgment in 2021 and closed them later that year.
Supporters credit the programme with lowering borrowing costs and preventing deflation. Critics point to higher asset and house prices that mostly benefited wealthier households, reduced market pressure on governments to cut debt, the Eurosystem's large footprint in bond markets, and the losses some Eurosystem central banks reported once rates rose and the interest they paid on reserves exceeded the income from bonds bought at low yields.