Arrival price is the market price of a security at the moment an order arrives at the trading desk, broker or market. It is usually taken as the mid price, the midpoint between the best bid and best offer, at the time the order is received. The term has two connected uses: as a benchmark against which the cost of executing the order is measured, and as the name of a type of execution algorithm that tries to complete the order close to that price.
The benchmark is the foundation of implementation shortfall, the measure of trading cost introduced by André Perold in 1988, which compares the result of actual trading with a paper portfolio filled instantly at the starting price. It is widely regarded as the fairest yardstick for a trader, because it is fixed before trading begins and cannot be affected by the order itself.
Arrival price as a benchmark
The cost of an order against its arrival price, often called slippage, is expressed in basis points:
- is the volume-weighted average price actually obtained.
- is the arrival price.
- is +1 for a buy order and -1 for a sell order, so that a positive result is always a cost.
Suppose an order to buy 100,000 shares arrives when the bid is 49.98 and the offer 50.02, an arrival price of 50.00. The order is filled over two hours at an average of 50.06. The cost is basis points, or 6,000 dollars on a trade of about 5 million dollars. Had the order been a sale filled at 50.06, the result would be -12 basis points, a gain against the benchmark.
In transaction cost analysis the figure is split into parts: half the bid-ask spread, the market impact of the order's own demand for liquidity, and the drift of the market during execution. Explicit costs such as commissions are added separately.
Comparison with other benchmarks
- VWAP. The volume-weighted average price of the day measures a trader against the market's own average. A large order moves that average, which flatters the result, and the benchmark ignores any price change between the decision and the trading.
- TWAP. The time-weighted average price has the same weakness and ignores volume.
- Closing price. The close suits index funds that are valued at it, but says little about trades done earlier in the day.
- Decision price. The price when the portfolio manager decided to trade comes before the arrival price. The gap between the two is a delay cost charged to the manager's process, not to the trader.
Arrival price algorithms
An arrival price algorithm, sometimes sold under the name implementation shortfall, is an execution strategy that aims to minimize expected slippage from the arrival price. It faces a trade-off. Trading quickly keeps the average close to the starting price but pushes the market; trading slowly reduces impact but leaves the order exposed to price moves for longer. The standard treatment of the problem is the framework published by Robert Almgren and Neil Chriss around 2000, in which the best schedule depends on the trader's tolerance for risk.
In practice the algorithm trades more heavily at the start and tapers off, unlike a VWAP schedule that follows the day's volume curve. The user typically sets an urgency or risk-aversion level, a maximum share of market volume, a limit price and an end time. Higher urgency suits a volatile stock or a small order; lower urgency suits a large order in a thinly traded one. Brokers include the type in their standard algo menus, and results are judged under a firm's best execution policy.
Limitations
A single order's result against arrival price is dominated by market movement during execution, which is largely chance, so conclusions need averages over many orders. The benchmark depends on an accurate time stamp, and a desk that delays recording an order's arrival can improve its apparent performance. In an illiquid security the midpoint may be a poor guide to the price at which any real size could trade.
The algorithms rely on models of impact and volatility estimated from past data, which can fail when liquidity dries up. A limit price may also leave part of the order unfilled, an opportunity cost that a full shortfall calculation should include but that simple slippage figures often omit.