An adverse development cover (ADC) is a form of retroactive reinsurance that protects an insurer against the risk that claims from business it has already written, and already reserved for, will cost more than expected. The reinsurer agrees to pay a share of any losses that exceed a retention, usually set at or above the reserves the insurer currently carries, up to an agreed limit. In return the insurer pays a premium at inception.
ADCs belong to the legacy or run-off segment of the reinsurance market, alongside the loss portfolio transfer (LPT), with which they are often combined. Buyers include insurers selling or closing a business line, groups seeking to reassure investors or rating agencies about old reserves, and acquirers protecting themselves against hidden deficiencies in a target's balance sheet. The cover is written by large reinsurers and by specialist legacy carriers.
How an adverse development cover works
An ADC is structured much like an aggregate excess of loss contract, but it applies to losses that have already occurred. The main terms are:
- The subject business. The accident years, classes of business and sometimes named claims covered, for example all commercial liability losses occurring before a given date.
- The retention. The level of cumulative paid losses, measured from an agreed date, above which the reinsurer starts to pay. It is commonly set at the carried claims reserve or slightly above it, so the insurer keeps the expected losses and cedes only deterioration.
- The limit and share. The maximum the reinsurer will pay, and the percentage of each loss above the retention it covers. Insurers often keep a co-participation, such as 10 or 20 per cent, so they retain an interest in managing claims well.
- The premium. A single payment reflecting the probability and timing of deterioration, the investment income the reinsurer expects to earn before paying, and its cost of capital.
Unlike an LPT, an ADC usually leaves the reserves and claims handling with the insurer; the reinsurer pays only once cumulative payments pass the retention, which may be many years later.
Combination with loss portfolio transfers
A common structure pairs the two. Under the LPT element, the reinsurer takes over the reserves up to their carried amount in exchange for a premium close to their discounted value. The ADC element then covers deterioration above that amount. Together they can transfer nearly all economic exposure to a block of old business, and are sometimes followed by a legal transfer of the policies themselves, for example a Part VII transfer in the United Kingdom.
A widely reported example came in 2017, when AIG bought a large ADC from National Indemnity, a Berkshire Hathaway company, covering a share of deterioration on a large pool of its US long-tail commercial reserves above a retention.
Accounting and regulatory treatment
Because the losses have already occurred, an ADC is retroactive reinsurance, and accounting regimes treat it differently from prospective cover. Under US GAAP, a gain arising when the premium is less than the recoverable is generally deferred and recognised over the settlement period rather than booked immediately, which prevents insurers from using retroactive covers to manufacture earnings. US statutory accounting has its own special rules for retroactive reinsurance.
Under IFRS 17, an ADC is a reinsurance contract held and is measured with its own fulfilment cash flows, risk adjustment and contractual service margin. Solvency regimes such as Solvency II allow the protection to reduce reserve risk in the solvency capital requirement if it transfers risk effectively, while adding counterparty risk on the reinsurer.
Risk transfer and pricing
To count as reinsurance rather than a deposit, the contract must transfer significant insurance risk. Accountants and regulators look at whether the reinsurer can suffer a material loss in reasonably possible scenarios; a market rule of thumb is a 10 per cent chance of a 10 per cent loss, though this is a heuristic rather than a rule. Pricing relies on reserve distributions produced with stochastic versions of the chain ladder and related methods, on payment patterns that drive the investment income on the premium, and on the reinsurer's view of claims inflation in long-tail lines.
Risks and criticism
For the cedant, the main residual risks are the limit being exhausted by severe deterioration and the reinsurer's ability to pay decades later, which is why ADCs are often collateralised or written only by highly rated counterparties; the resulting reinsurance recoverable may be large relative to the cedant's capital. For the reinsurer, the risk is mispricing long-tail exposures such as asbestos, environmental or abuse claims. Critics note that ADCs can obscure weak reserving by moving the problem off the balance sheet, which is why investors and analysts usually read the announcement of a large ADC alongside any accompanying reserve strengthening.