Reinsurance recoverables are the amounts an insurer expects to recover from its reinsurers under its reinsurance contracts. They have two parts: recoverables on paid losses, for claims the insurer has already settled and billed to reinsurers, and recoverables on unpaid losses, the reinsurers' share of the insurer's outstanding claims reserves, including IBNR. Some definitions also include ceded unearned premium.
Recoverables are often among the largest assets on a non-life insurer's balance sheet, especially for companies that cede a large share of their business through quota share or catastrophe programmes. Because the insurer remains liable to policyholders whether or not reinsurers pay, recoverables expose the insurer to credit risk on its reinsurance panel. Accounting standards, solvency regimes and rating agencies all have specific rules for measuring and stressing them.
How recoverables arise
When a loss occurs, the insurer records the gross claim and, separately, the portion recoverable under its treaties and facultative covers. For an excess of loss layer, the recoverable is the part of the loss above the attachment point; for proportional business it is the ceded share. As claims are paid, the insurer bills reinsurers through accounts or cash calls, and the recoverable on unpaid losses moves into recoverable on paid losses until it is collected.
Timing gaps are normal. Reinsurers check claims, apply terms such as the hours clause and may dispute coverage, so a portion of paid recoverables is typically overdue at any time. Large or ageing balances are a warning sign of disputes or reinsurer weakness. Long-tail lines add a further complication: recoverables on unpaid losses in liability or workers' compensation business may not be billed for many years, so the cedant carries exposure to reinsurers whose financial strength may change greatly before collection.
Credit risk and collateral
Insurers manage counterparty risk on recoverables in several ways:
- Security standards. Minimum credit ratings for reinsurers on the panel, with limits per counterparty to avoid concentration risk.
- Collateral. A reinsurance collateral trust, a letter of credit or a funds withheld arrangement, especially for reinsurers not authorised in the cedant's jurisdiction.
- Contract terms. Downgrade clauses that allow the cedant to cancel, demand collateral or commute the contract if a reinsurer's rating falls.
- Commutation and settlement. Negotiated settlements with weak or run-off reinsurers, under a commutation clause or by agreement.
Provisions and accounting
Recoverables are reported net of an allowance for amounts that may not be collected, similar in spirit to an allowance for doubtful accounts. Under IFRS 17, reinsurance contracts held are measured separately from the underlying contracts and the estimate of cash flows must reflect the risk of non-performance by the reinsurer. Under Solvency II, recoverables are adjusted for expected losses due to counterparty default, and the counterparty default risk module of the solvency capital requirement adds capital for the possibility of reinsurer failure.
US Schedule F
In the United States, property and casualty insurers report reinsurance in Schedule F of the statutory annual statement prescribed by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Schedule F lists recoverables by reinsurer and calculates a provision for reinsurance, a statutory liability that reduces surplus for amounts that are overdue, in dispute or owed by reinsurers that have not posted adequate collateral. Under the credit for reinsurance rules, recoverables from authorised reinsurers receive full credit, while those from unauthorised reinsurers receive credit only to the extent they are collateralised. Reforms have allowed reduced collateral for certified reinsurers and, following the covered agreements with the European Union and the United Kingdom, for reinsurers from qualifying reciprocal jurisdictions.
Analysis and ratios
Analysts commonly compare recoverables with the insurer's capital:
Here policyholder surplus is the statutory capital of the insurer, described under policyholder surplus. An insurer with recoverables of 600 million and surplus of 1,200 million has a ratio of , or 50 per cent; a failure of reinsurers owing a fifth of the recoverables would remove 120 million, or 10 per cent, of surplus. Rating agencies also look at the quality mix of the panel, the share that is collateralised and the proportion of overdue balances. Recoverables tend to rise sharply after major catastrophes, which is when reinsurer credit quality matters most and when retrocessionaire credit exposure can spread losses through the reinsurance chain. Write-offs of uncollectable recoverables flow directly to the income statement as an increase in net incurred losses.