Wakalah sukuk, also called sukuk al-wakalah, are sukuk in which the money raised from investors is handed to the originator to manage as their agent. Wakalah is the Arabic term for an agency contract, and the agent is the wakil. The originator invests the proceeds in a portfolio of Shariah-compliant assets, usually a mix of leased assets and receivables, and passes the income to holders as periodic distributions. It earns a fee for its work and, typically, keeps any return above the expected profit as an incentive fee.
The structure has become one of the most widely used in international sukuk, favoured by governments, banks, development institutions and companies because it can be built from assets the originator already owns and lets a single framework support many issues under a sukuk issuance programme. It belongs to the family of asset-based sukuk: holders rely on the originator's undertakings rather than on the assets alone. The contract follows the wakalah principles set out in standards of AAOIFI, and supervisors apply guidance from the IFSB when banks hold or issue such paper.
How the structure works
The parties are the sukuk issuer vehicle, which issues the certificates and acts as trustee for holders, and the originator, which acts as wakil, obligor and servicer. A typical deal runs in five steps:
- Issue. The issuer-trustee sells certificates to investors and receives the proceeds, which it holds on trust for them.
- Appointment of the wakil. Under a wakalah agreement the trustee appoints the originator as its agent to invest the proceeds in a defined portfolio according to investment criteria.
- Building the portfolio. The trustee, through the wakil, buys a share of tangible assets from the originator, often property or equipment that the originator then leases back, and enters into murabaha or commodity contracts that create receivables.
- Distributions. The wakil collects rentals and profit on the portfolio and pays the trustee enough to meet each periodic distribution, which the trustee passes on to holders.
- Dissolution. At maturity, or earlier after a default, the trustee exercises a purchase undertaking under which the originator buys the portfolio at an exercise price equal to the face amount plus unpaid distributions.
Detailed terms on what the wakil may buy, how it reports and what it must do with surplus cash are often set out in a separate investment plan, sometimes called a wakalah investment mandate.
Expected profit, incentive fee and shortfalls
Holders are promised an expected return rather than interest. The documents state an expected periodic distribution amount, calculated like a coupon from the face amount and an agreed profit rate. If the portfolio earns more than this amount, the surplus is kept by the wakil as an incentive fee, often held in a reserve that can be used to top up later periods. A basic wakalah fee, often nominal, is also stated.
If the portfolio earns less than the expected amount, the wakil may make a liquidity facility available, usually an interest-free loan (qard) repaid from later income or from the exercise price. In practice the combination of the reserve, the liquidity facility and the purchase undertaking means holders receive the same stream of payments they would receive from a bond of the same originator, which is why rating agencies treat wakalah sukuk as senior unsecured obligations of the obligor.
Tangibility and the asset mix
The mix of the portfolio is central to the structure. Under the prevailing Shariah view, certificates representing mostly debt, such as murabaha receivables, cannot trade at a market price, because that would amount to selling debt for more or less than its face value. Wakalah sukuk therefore keep a minimum share of tangible assets in the portfolio, commonly more than half and often set at 51 per cent, with the rest in murabaha or similar receivables.
The documents include a tangibility test and a procedure for falling below it. If the tangible share drops, for example because leased assets are destroyed or sold, the originator must replace them. Some deals provide that if the ratio falls below a lower threshold the certificates must be delisted and may only trade at face value, or that the event leads to early dissolution. Rules for substituting assets keep the portfolio stable over long tenors.
Uses and Shariah debate
Governments in the Gulf, Asia and Africa use wakalah structures for international sukuk, and banks use them for senior funding and for Tier 2 capital instruments, where subordination is added through the terms. The same structure is used for green sukuk, with the proceeds earmarked for eligible projects.
Critics point out that the purchase undertaking at face value moves the risk of the portfolio back to the originator, so that holders do not bear real ownership risk. AAOIFI's 2008 statement on sukuk questioned buy-back promises at face value in partnership and agency sukuk, and scholars differ on how far the tangible, lease-based part of a wakalah portfolio answers that concern. The structure remains in wide use, but each deal relies on its own Shariah board approval, and the issue is a recurring theme in studies of Sharia non-compliance risk in the sukuk market.
Ref 1110000140