What is Unconventional Monetary Policy?
Definition: Unconventional monetary policy is the set of tools a central bank uses to ease financial conditions when cutting its short-term policy rate is no longer possible or no longer enough, such as large asset purchases and guidance about future rates.
Unconventional monetary policy, also called non-standard monetary policy, covers measures that go beyond the normal practice of steering a single overnight interest rate. In ordinary times a central bank conducts monetary policy by raising or lowering that rate and letting the change pass through to bank lending, bond yields and the exchange rate. When the rate approaches the zero lower bound, or when markets are too disrupted for rate changes to pass through, central banks turn to other instruments that act on longer-term rates, credit spreads and expectations.
The main tools are quantitative easing and other asset purchases, forward guidance, negative policy rates, targeted lending schemes and yield curve control. Most were developed or greatly expanded after the global financial crisis of 2007 to 2009 and again during the pandemic of 2020, by the Federal Reserve, the European Central Bank, the Bank of Japan and the Bank of England among others. What counted as unconventional in 2008 has since become a standard part of the toolkit.
Background: the limits of interest rate policy
A central bank cannot easily push its policy rate far below zero, because banks and households could hold cash, which pays a zero return, instead of deposits. Once the rate is near that floor, further cuts are unavailable even if the economy remains weak and inflation is below target. Economists describe the extreme case as a liquidity trap, in which extra money is simply held rather than spent.
Japan met the problem first. After its asset bubble burst in the early 1990s, the Bank of Japan cut rates to almost zero and in 2001 began a policy of quantitative easing aimed at the level of bank reserves, which ran until 2006, while the economy struggled with mild deflation. Other major central banks reached the floor in late 2008 and early 2009, and the experiments multiplied.
Main tools
Unconventional policy is a family of measures that can be used alone or together:
- Asset purchases. The central bank buys government bonds and sometimes mortgage-backed securities, corporate bonds or other assets, paying with newly created reserves. Purchases lower long-term yields by reducing the supply of duration held by private investors and compressing the term premium, and signal that rates will stay low.
- Forward guidance. The central bank states how it expects to set rates in future, either in terms of time or of economic conditions, so that markets price a lower path of rates.
- Negative rates. The central bank charges banks for some of the reserves they hold with it, as the ECB did from June 2014 and several European central banks did in the 2010s. Under a negative interest rate policy the floor is below zero rather than at it.
- Targeted lending. Cheap long-term funding is offered to banks on condition that they lend to firms and households, as in the ECB's targeted longer-term refinancing operations and the Bank of England's Funding for Lending Scheme, launched in 2012.
- Yield curve control. The central bank sets a target for a longer-term bond yield and buys whatever quantity is needed to hold it, as the Bank of Japan did for ten-year government bonds from 2016.
Examples from major central banks
The Federal Reserve cut its policy rate to a range of zero to 0.25 per cent in December 2008 and ran several rounds of large-scale asset purchases between late 2008 and 2014, combined with date-based and then outcome-based forward guidance. It bought assets again on a large scale from March 2020. The Bank of England began buying gilts in March 2009 through its Asset Purchase Facility. The ECB first relied mainly on long-term lending to banks, announced its Outright Monetary Transactions programme for government bonds in 2012, and began broad public-sector bond purchases in 2015.
The Bank of Japan went furthest. Under the policies associated with Abenomics it launched quantitative and qualitative easing in April 2013, introduced a negative rate on part of bank reserves in January 2016 and added yield curve control in September 2016. It ended its negative rate and yield curve control in March 2024.
Effects, risks and exit
Most studies find that asset purchases and forward guidance lowered long-term yields and supported output and inflation, especially when markets were disrupted, though estimates of the size of the effect vary widely and appear to shrink with repeated use. Criticisms include the following: large purchases raise asset prices and may widen wealth inequality; prolonged low or negative rates squeeze bank margins and can encourage excessive risk-taking; buying government debt on a large scale blurs the line between monetary and fiscal policy; and central banks face losses on their bond holdings when rates rise.
Exit raises its own problems. Central banks have raised rates while keeping large balance sheets, paying interest on reserves to control short-term rates, and have shrunk their holdings gradually through quantitative tightening, by letting bonds mature or, in the Bank of England's case, also selling them. How large a balance sheet should remain in normal times is still debated.
External links
Ref 1100001935