What is UCC Article 4A?
Definition: The part of the Uniform Commercial Code that sets the legal rules for commercial funds transfers, including who bears the loss when a payment order is wrong or unauthorised.
UCC Article 4A is the part of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) that governs wholesale funds transfers in the United States. It was drafted by the Uniform Law Commission and the American Law Institute and adopted by the states from the early 1990s, and its rules apply to credit transfers made by wire, through Fedwire Funds Service, through CHIPS and by other bank-to-bank means. Before the Article, the law for these transfers was a patchwork of contract and common law.
Article 4A is a state law, so its exact wording varies slightly among states, but the text is largely uniform. It fills the gap left by Articles 3 and 4, which cover checks and other Negotiable Instrument items, and by consumer legislation. A funds transfer is the series of payment orders by which money moves from an originator to a beneficiary, and the Article deals with each link in the chain.
Scope and parties
A funds transfer begins when the originator issues a Payment Order to its bank, an instruction to pay a fixed amount to a beneficiary. The sender is the party giving an order, the receiving bank is the party that gets it, and one or more intermediary banks may sit between the originator's bank and the beneficiary's bank. A bank that accepts an order becomes obliged to execute it and, in turn, is entitled to payment from the sender. Acceptance generally occurs when the bank executes the order or receives payment for it.
The Article excludes any transfer that is governed by the Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA), which protects consumers. Consumer transfers are therefore handled under Regulation E and the rules for an Unauthorized Electronic Fund Transfer. This is why the Article is described as a commercial and wholesale law.
Security procedures and unauthorized orders
The central rule on unauthorised orders turns on security procedures. A payment order is the customer's order if the customer authorised it, or if it is verified under an agreed security procedure that is commercially reasonable and the bank accepted it in good faith and in compliance with that procedure. If the procedure is met, the customer bears the loss even where the order was in fact sent by a fraudster, unless the customer can show that the order did not come from a person with access to the procedure's controls.
Whether a procedure is commercially reasonable is a legal question decided in light of the customer's circumstances, the type of orders and the alternatives offered. If the bank offered a reasonable procedure and the customer declined it in writing, the customer is bound by orders accepted in compliance with the one chosen. This allocation has been central in cases involving corporate account takeover and business email compromise.
Refunds, errors and time limits
Where an accepted order is not authorised and not effective, the bank must refund the amount received from the customer with interest. The customer must however examine the notice or statement and tell the bank within a reasonable time, and generally within one year of receiving notification, or the customer is barred from asserting the claim. Interest may be lost where notice is later than a reasonable time not exceeding 90 days.
The Article also contains a "money-back guarantee": if a transfer is not completed, the originator is entitled to a refund, subject to limited exceptions. Where an order identifies the beneficiary by name and number, a bank without knowledge of any inconsistency may rely on the number, which matters in misdirected-payment disputes. Cancellation and amendment are limited; see Revocation (Payment Order). Consequential damages are generally not recoverable unless the bank has agreed to them in writing.
Regulation J and the Federal Reserve
For transfers sent over Fedwire, the Federal Reserve Banks' operating rules are set out in Regulation J, subpart B, and incorporate Article 4A so that it applies even in states that have varied the text. The Federal Reserve Banks publish operating circulars that complement these provisions, and the Federal Reserve Board issues the regulation. CHIPS and private networks use their own rules, which the Article allows participants to adopt by agreement.
Related practical subjects are described under Wire Transfer, Funds Transfer and Wire Fraud (Federal Offense). The Article is also relevant to a bank's liability in cases of misdirected or fraudulently induced payments.
External links
Ref 1210000761