Types of tax by tax base is a way of classifying taxes according to what they are charged on: a quantity of goods, total spending, a source of pollution, the value of assets, or simply the number of people. Most readers know the two great bases of modern tax systems, income tax and consumption taxes such as VAT. The taxes described here either sit alongside them or offer alternatives that economists have proposed or governments have tried.
Public finance economists, statistics offices and bodies such as the IMF and OECD use these categories to compare tax systems and record revenue consistently. The base matters because it decides who ultimately pays, through tax incidence, how far the tax changes behaviour, and how easy it is to collect. Specific and environmental taxes are mostly levied on goods; expenditure and poll taxes on people; capital taxes and capital levies on wealth. The general criteria for judging them are set out in principles of tax design.
Specific Tax
A specific tax is a tax charged as a fixed amount per unit of quantity, such as per litre of fuel, per pack of cigarettes or per litre of pure alcohol, rather than as a percentage of price. The alternative is an ad valorem tax, which is a percentage of value. Specific taxes are common for excise taxes on fuel, alcohol and tobacco.
A fuel duty of 0.50 per litre on 40 million litres raises 20 million, whatever the pump price. This makes revenue more stable and easy to administer, and it falls equally on cheap and expensive brands, which suits a goal of cutting total consumption. Its drawback is that inflation erodes its real value unless the rate is raised or indexed, and it is a larger share of the price of cheaper products. Many countries combine the two forms, as with tobacco duties that have both a specific and an ad valorem element.
Expenditure Tax
An expenditure tax is a direct tax on a person's total consumption spending over a year, rather than on income. Taxable spending is usually found by taking income and subtracting net saving, so saving is untaxed until it is spent. Unlike a sales tax or VAT, which are collected from sellers at a flat rate on each sale, an expenditure tax is assessed on individuals and can have progressive rates.
The idea was argued most fully by Nicholas Kaldor in his 1955 book An Expenditure Tax, and later by the UK Meade Committee in 1978. Kaldor's ideas influenced India, which levied an expenditure tax on high spenders from the late 1950s before abolishing it in the 1960s, and Ceylon, now Sri Lanka, also tried one. Supporters say it removes the tax bias against saving; critics point to the difficulty of measuring saving and the temptation to hide spending.
Environmental Tax
An environmental tax, in the statistical definition used by the OECD, Eurostat and the IMF, is a tax whose base is a physical unit, or a proxy for one, of something with a proven, specific harmful effect on the environment. The definition depends on the base, not on the tax's name or the purpose of the revenue. The main groups are energy taxes, including fuel duties; transport taxes such as vehicle registration and road taxes; pollution taxes on emissions and waste; and taxes on resource extraction.
Economically, many environmental taxes are meant to act as a Pigouvian tax, raising the price of an activity to reflect the cost of its negative externality. A carbon tax on each tonne of carbon dioxide emitted is the clearest example. In practice, energy taxes on fuel raise most of the revenue. Environmental taxes are also recorded in environmental and natural capital accounting.
Capital Tax
A capital tax, in government finance statistics and the national accounts, is a tax levied at irregular and infrequent intervals on the value of assets or net worth, or on assets transferred between people as legacies or gifts. The two main kinds are capital levies and taxes on capital transfers, such as inheritance tax, estate duty and gift tax.
The statistical point is that these taxes fall on the stock of wealth when it changes hands, not on regular income, so the national accounts treat them as capital transfers rather than current revenue. A capital tax is different from capital gains tax, which taxes the rise in an asset's value when it is sold and is normally classed as a tax on income. It also differs from recurrent taxes on property, such as annual taxes on land and buildings, covered in property tax in government finance.
Capital Levy
A capital levy is a one-off tax on the value of assets or net worth, usually imposed in an emergency to pay down public debt. It differs from a recurring wealth tax, which is charged every year at a lower rate. Because it is levied once, on wealth that already exists, economists argue that it need not discourage future saving, provided people believe it will not be repeated.
Capital levies were widely debated after the First World War, when many countries faced very high debts, and several European countries applied them after one or both world wars. Japan imposed a one-off property tax in 1946, and West Germany's burden-sharing law of 1952 taxed surviving wealth to compensate those who had lost property in the war. The practical problems are valuing assets, preventing capital flight once a levy is expected, and the risk that a levy, once used, is expected again.
Poll Tax
A poll tax, or head tax, is a fixed amount charged to each adult regardless of income or wealth. It is a lump sum tax, so economists note that it does not distort decisions to work or save. It is, however, highly regressive, taking a larger share of income from poorer people, and it has often provoked resistance, as in the English Peasants' Revolt of 1381.
The best-known modern example is the UK Community Charge, introduced in Scotland in 1989 and in England and Wales in 1990 to replace domestic rates as a local tax. It led to mass non-payment and protests, including a riot in London in March 1990, and was replaced by Council Tax in 1993. In the United States, poll taxes required to vote were used to exclude poorer and Black voters; the Twenty-fourth Amendment of 1964 banned them in federal elections, and the Supreme Court struck them down for state elections in 1966.
Ref 1010001532