US students and families pay for higher education with several kinds of borrowing. Most of it comes from the federal government through the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program, run by the US Department of Education; the rest comes from banks, credit unions, state agencies and other private funders. A student loan of each type has its own eligibility rules, interest terms, borrowing limits and repayment protections.
Federal loans are applied for through the federal aid application and are part of the wider package described under types of student financial aid. Their rates are fixed by law, most require no credit check, and they come with options such as federal repayment plans, deferment and forgiveness programmes. A federal law enacted in July 2025 changed repayment plans and borrowing limits for loans made from 1 July 2026, so rules for older and newer loans differ. Private loans and income share agreements sit outside this system.
Direct Subsidized Loan
A Direct Subsidized Loan is a federal student loan for undergraduates who show financial need. Its defining feature is the interest subsidy: the Department of Education pays the interest while the student is enrolled at least half-time, during the six-month grace period after leaving school and during periods of authorised deferment. The student therefore leaves school owing only the amount borrowed.
The amount depends on need, as calculated by the school, and on annual and lifetime limits set by law. For a dependent first-year undergraduate the subsidised amount has long been capped at 3,500 dollars, rising in later years, within a 23,000-dollar aggregate limit for subsidised borrowing. Graduate and professional students lost access to subsidised loans for loans made from 1 July 2012. Students who need more than the subsidised limit, or who do not show need, may borrow Direct Unsubsidized Loans, on which interest accrues from disbursement. Both carry a fixed rate set each year by a formula linked to the ten-year Treasury note.
Direct PLUS Loan
A Direct PLUS Loan is a federal loan for graduate or professional students (Grad PLUS) and for parents of dependent undergraduates (Parent PLUS). Unlike other federal student loans, PLUS loans involve a credit check, though only for adverse credit history, such as recent defaults, bankruptcy or foreclosure, rather than a credit score. A borrower with adverse history may still qualify with an endorser or by documenting extenuating circumstances.
PLUS loans have historically been available up to the full cost of attendance minus other aid, at a higher fixed rate and fee than Direct Subsidized or Unsubsidized Loans. Parent PLUS loans are the parent's legal debt, not the student's. The July 2025 federal law ends Grad PLUS lending to new borrowers from 1 July 2026 and introduces caps on Parent PLUS borrowing, replacing open-ended limits with fixed annual and aggregate amounts. Borrowers with loans already disbursed keep their existing terms, subject to transition rules.
Stafford Loan
Stafford Loan is the older name for the main federal student loans for undergraduate and graduate students, in subsidised and unsubsidised forms. The loans were named in 1988 after Senator Robert Stafford of Vermont. Until 2010 many Stafford loans were made by private lenders under the Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) Program, with the government guaranteeing them and paying lenders subsidies, while others were made directly by the government.
Legislation in 2010 ended new FFEL lending from 1 July 2010, so all new federal student loans have since been made as Direct Loans. Direct Subsidized and Direct Unsubsidized Loans are the direct successors of Stafford loans, and the Stafford name still appears in older paperwork, school materials and loan histories. Outstanding FFEL Stafford loans continue to be held by commercial lenders and guaranty agencies, and borrowers can bring them into the Direct Loan programme through consolidation, which can be needed to qualify for some federal forgiveness and repayment options.
Federal Perkins Loan
A Federal Perkins Loan was a low-interest federal student loan for undergraduate and graduate students with exceptional financial need. It was a campus-based programme: participating schools acted as the lender, using a revolving fund of federal capital, school contributions and repayments from earlier borrowers. The loans carried a fixed 5 percent interest rate, a nine-month grace period and an interest subsidy while the borrower was in school.
Congress did not renew the programme, and its authority expired on 30 September 2017, with final disbursements allowed until 30 June 2018. Existing Perkins loans continue to be repaid to the school or to the Department of Education. Perkins loans carry their own cancellation provisions, under which part or all of the balance can be cancelled after years of full-time service in occupations such as teaching in low-income schools, nursing, law enforcement and military service. Perkins loans can also be consolidated into a Direct Consolidation Loan, though cancellation rights specific to Perkins are then lost.
Private Student Loan
A private student loan is an education loan made by a bank, credit union, online lender or state-affiliated agency rather than by the federal government. Pricing is based on the borrower's credit, so rates may be fixed or variable and vary widely; many undergraduates need a co-signer, and some lenders later offer co-signer release after a run of on-time payments. Private loans are often used to cover costs beyond federal limits.
Private loans lack most federal protections: there are no income-driven plans, no Public Service Loan Forgiveness and only lender-specific forbearance. Under Regulation Z, lenders must give specific disclosures at application, approval and consummation, and the borrower has a short period after approval in which to accept the terms. Like federal loans, private student loans are generally hard to discharge in bankruptcy, requiring proof of undue hardship, though courts have treated some loans that exceed qualifying education costs differently.
An income share agreement (ISA) is a form of education funding in which a student receives money for tuition or training and agrees to pay a fixed percentage of future income for a set period instead of repaying a fixed loan amount. Contracts usually set a minimum income below which no payment is due and a payment cap, often expressed as a multiple of the amount funded. ISAs have been offered by some universities, coding bootcamps and investment platforms.
Promoters presented ISAs as an alternative to debt, but regulators disagreed. In 2021 the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau took action against an ISA provider and stated that such contracts can be private education loans under the Truth in Lending Act, which brings disclosure and other lending rules into play. State regulators and courts have reached similar conclusions, and several large ISA programmes have since closed. Payment amounts depend on earnings, so the total cost can be higher or lower than a comparable loan.
How the loan types compare
| Type | Lender | Credit check | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct Subsidized Loan | Federal government | No | Current, undergraduates with need |
| Direct PLUS Loan | Federal government | Adverse history only | Grad PLUS ends for new borrowers from July 2026 |
| Stafford Loan | Government or FFEL lenders | No | Name replaced by Direct Loans; FFEL ended 2010 |
| Federal Perkins Loan | Schools | No | Ended 2017; existing loans repaid |
| Private student loan | Banks and other lenders | Yes | Current |
| Income share agreement | Schools and investors | Varies | Treated as private loans by regulators |
External links
Ref 1120000290