Types of check fraud are the main ways in which checks and similar paper instruments are abused to take money from payers, payees or banks. Check fraud persists despite the shift to electronic payments because a check carries the account details and a signature in a form that is easy to copy, and because it is processed on the assumption that the document is genuine. Variants differ in whether the check is stolen, fabricated, altered or simply written without funds behind it.
Responsibility for the loss depends on the type. In the United States, Articles 3 and 4 of the Uniform Commercial Code allocate loss between the bank that pays, the bank that takes the deposit and the customer, while Regulation CC governs funds availability. Banks counter the schemes with positive pay, image analysis and deposit monitoring. The sections below cover seven forms.
Check Theft
Check theft is the stealing of checks from mail, mailboxes, offices, vehicles or the trash. A stolen check can be cashed by forging the endorsement, or its details can be changed by check washing, in which ink is removed chemically and the payee and amount rewritten. Stolen blank checks and account numbers can also be used to make counterfeits. Mail theft rose strongly in the early 2020s, according to US law enforcement and banking regulators, and the offence also falls under 18 U.S.C. 1708. Protections include using secure collection boxes, paying electronically, using gel pens, reviewing statements promptly and, for businesses, positive pay.
Counterfeit Check
A counterfeit check is a check made from scratch, often with desktop tools or printed stock, that imitates a real account or bank, using real routing and account numbers or invented ones. It differs from an altered check, where a genuine item is changed, and from a forged one, where a genuine blank is signed without authority. Counterfeits are widely used in overpayment scams, in which a seller or job candidate is sent an inflated check and asked to return the difference, as in employment and money-transfer scams. The bank may credit the deposit, but when the item is returned as fake, the depositor owes the money back. Banks use image analysis, fraud scoring and account checks to catch such items.
Forged Endorsement
A forged endorsement is the signing of the payee's name on the back of a check without authority, usually on a stolen item, so that it can be cashed or deposited. Under the UCC, an unauthorised signature is generally ineffective, so the payee is treated as never having been paid, and the paying bank may recover from the bank that accepted the deposit, which in effect usually bears the loss because it took the check from the thief. Banks therefore verify identity at deposit and are cautious about third-party checks. The case differs from a forged maker signature, where the drawer's own name is forged.
Forged Maker
A forged maker, or forged drawer, signature is a check whose signature in the drawer's name was written by someone without authority, often on stolen blank stock. Under the UCC the unauthorised signature does not bind the account holder, so the paying bank usually cannot charge the account and carries the loss, unless the holder was negligent in a way that contributed to the forgery or failed to report it in time after receiving statements. The code gives customers a duty to examine statements and report unauthorised items, with an overall limit of one year. Banks compare signatures on large items, and businesses use positive pay, which matches each presented check against a list of issued ones.
Shotgunning
Shotgunning is the writing of many bad checks to many merchants in a short time, often on an account that is empty, new or about to be closed, so that the losses are spread before any bank or merchant notices. The pattern relies on the delay between a check being accepted and being returned. It is related to kiting, where float between accounts is exploited, but there the offender may later cover the checks. Merchants and check-verification services guard against it by sharing negative-file data, and prosecutors treat a wave of bad checks as evidence of intent.
Paper Hanging
Paper hanging is a slang phrase for passing worthless, forged or closed-account checks, typically as a repeated pattern by the same person. It covers writing checks on an account the person knows to be closed or overdrawn, and it overlaps with ordinary bad-check offences defined by state law, which usually require intent to defraud and often notice and a period to pay before charges. Repeated conduct, large totals or the use of a false identity increases criminal exposure. Merchants use verification services, identification checks and limits on accepting checks from new customers. The practice is close to shotgunning but is usually used for individual passing of bad paper over time.
Money Order Fraud
Money order fraud uses counterfeit or altered money orders as payment, or as part of an overpayment scam. A money order seems safer than a personal check, since it is prepaid, but fakes can be convincing, and altered genuine orders raise a small amount into a large one. When a deposited order is found to be counterfeit, the bank reverses the deposit, so the loss falls on the victim, who has often already sent goods or wired a refund. Issuers offer verification: postal money orders can be checked with the postal service, and commercial ones by contacting the issuer. A cashier's check can be faked in the same way, so banks may delay releasing funds on such deposits.
How the types compare
| Type | Instrument | Usual loss-bearer (UCC rules) |
|---|---|---|
| Check theft | Genuine check, stolen | Depends on the later misuse |
| Counterfeit check | Fabricated item | Depositor, if returned after credit |
| Forged endorsement | Genuine check, payee signature forged | Usually the depositary bank |
| Forged maker | Drawer signature forged | Usually the paying bank |
| Shotgunning and paper hanging | Genuine but unfunded checks | Merchants who accept them |
| Money order fraud | Fake or altered order | The depositor |
Ref 1140000239