Title insurance is a form of insurance that indemnifies the holder against financial loss arising from defects in the title to a piece of real estate. Typical defects include an unpaid lien, an error in a recorded document, a missing heir with a claim to the property, or a forged signature somewhere in the chain of ownership. The policy is bought once, at the time of a purchase or a refinancing, and covers problems that already existed on the date it was issued, even if nobody discovers them until years later.
The product is most closely associated with the United States, where almost every residential purchase financed with a mortgage involves at least one title policy. Countries with state-guaranteed land registers use it far less. In the US, title insurance is regulated by the states, usually through the state insurance department, and it sits alongside the closing process governed by the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA).
How title insurance differs from other insurance
Most insurance looks forward: homeowners insurance covers fire or theft during the policy term. Title insurance looks backward. It covers losses from events and documents that predate the policy, such as a fraudulent deed signed decades earlier.
Because the risk is mainly about the past, title insurers spend much of their effort preventing claims rather than paying them. Before issuing a policy, the insurer or its agent carries out a title search of public records, reviews any abstract of title, and requires known problems to be cleared, for example by paying off an old mortgage and recording a release of lien. As a result, the share of premium paid out in claims is low compared with most property and casualty lines, while the cost of searching, examining and closing is high.
Owner's and lender's policies
There are two main kinds of policy, and a single transaction often uses both:
- Lender's policy. Protects the mortgage lender up to the outstanding loan amount. Lenders, and the secondary-market buyers of loans such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, normally require one as a condition of the loan. Coverage falls as the loan is repaid.
- Owner's policy. Protects the buyer's own equity, usually up to the purchase price. It is optional in most states, and who pays for it depends on local custom and negotiation: in some areas the seller customarily pays, in others the buyer. Coverage generally lasts as long as the owner or the owner's heirs have an interest in the property.
Both policies are paid for with a single premium at closing, listed among the closing costs on the Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure (CD). When both are bought at the same time, insurers commonly offer a discounted simultaneous-issue rate for the second policy.
What a policy covers and excludes
A standard policy covers losses if title turns out to be vested in someone other than the insured, if the title is subject to a defect, lien or encumbrance not listed in the policy, if the title is unmarketable, or if there is no legal access to the land. It also obliges the insurer to defend the insured against a covered claim in court.
Each policy lists exceptions in a schedule. These typically include matters a survey or inspection would reveal, recorded easements, unpaid property taxes not yet due, rights of parties in possession, and any specific items found in the search that the parties chose to accept. Standard exclusions cover zoning and other government regulation, defects the insured created or knew about, and problems arising after the policy date. Additional protection can be bought through endorsements. Many US insurers use standard forms developed by the American Land Title Association (ALTA), a trade body.
Regulation and pricing
In the United States, title insurance is regulated state by state. Some states set or promulgate the premium rates that every insurer must charge, others require insurers to file rates for approval, and a few leave pricing more open. Premiums are usually calculated on a sliding scale tied to the purchase price or loan amount. Most policies are sold through title agents, attorneys or escrow companies, which handle the search and the closing and keep a large part of the premium; the underwriting insurer carries the claim risk. Iowa is a notable exception, where private title insurance on Iowa property is not permitted and a state-run title guaranty programme fills that role.
At federal level, RESPA's anti-kickback provisions, now enforced by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), prohibit paying referral fees to the real estate agents, lenders or builders who steer customers to a title company, and they restrict a seller from requiring a buyer to use a particular title insurer.
Criticism and alternatives
Critics argue that title insurance is expensive relative to the claims it pays and that competition works poorly, because the consumer rarely chooses the provider: the choice is usually made by the lender, the agent or the settlement agent. Supporters reply that the low claims ratio reflects the work done before closing.
Alternatives include attorney title opinions, still used in some states, and government-guaranteed land registration. Under the Torrens system, used in Australia, parts of Canada and elsewhere, the state register itself is conclusive evidence of ownership and an assurance fund compensates people who lose out through registration errors.
External links
Ref 1170000153