A tax credit is an amount that a taxpayer may subtract directly from the tax otherwise owed. A credit of 1,000 reduces the tax bill by 1,000, whatever the taxpayer's income or tax rate. Governments use tax credits to support particular groups, such as low-paid workers and families with children, or to encourage activities such as research, investment in deprived areas or the purchase of energy-efficient equipment.
Tax credits are often confused with deductions and allowances, which reduce taxable income rather than the tax itself. They are a common form of tax expenditure, the revenue a government gives up through special provisions in the tax code, and in many countries they deliver sums comparable to direct spending programmes.
Tax credits versus deductions
The value of a deduction depends on the taxpayer's marginal tax rate; the value of a credit does not. The tax saving from each is:
where is the amount deducted from income, is the marginal tax rate and is the credit. A deduction of 1,000 saves 200 for a taxpayer on a 20 per cent rate and 400 for one on a 40 per cent rate. A credit of 1,000 saves 1,000 for both. Because of this, credits are generally seen as fairer to lower earners, while deductions give more help to people on higher rates. A credit of 200 would give the 20 per cent taxpayer the same saving as the 1,000 deduction.
Refundable and non-refundable credits
The most important design choice is what happens when the credit exceeds the tax owed.
- Non-refundable credits can reduce the tax bill only to zero. Any unused part is lost, unless the rules allow it to be carried forward to later years.
- Refundable credits are paid out in full. If the credit is larger than the tax owed, the government pays the difference to the taxpayer.
- Partly refundable credits combine the two, paying out only part of any excess.
Suppose a household owes 600 in income tax and qualifies for a credit of 1,000. A non-refundable credit cuts the bill to zero and the remaining 400 is wasted. A refundable credit cuts the bill to zero and the household receives a payment of 400. Refundable credits therefore reach people with little or no tax liability, which is why they are used to support low-income households; in this respect they resemble a negative income tax.
Common examples
In the United States, the Earned Income Tax Credit is a refundable credit for low- and moderate-income workers that rises with earnings up to a point and then phases out. The child tax credit is partly refundable, and several other dependent-related credits support families. Business credits include the research credit, which rewards increases in qualifying research and development, and the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit, which supports affordable rental housing. An overview of these appears under US federal tax credits; the Internal Revenue Service administers them.
The United Kingdom long paid Working Tax Credit and Child Tax Credit, administered by HM Revenue and Customs, before moving claimants to Universal Credit, a benefit paid outside the tax system. Many countries also offer R&D credits for companies. A different kind of credit is the foreign tax credit, which allows tax paid abroad to be set against domestic tax on the same income and is a main tool of double taxation relief.
Tax credits in government finance statistics
Statistical manuals have to decide whether a credit is a reduction in tax revenue or a form of government spending. The IMF's Government Finance Statistics Manual 2014 (GFSM 2014) and the System of National Accounts distinguish between credits that can only reduce a liability and those that are payable. A non-payable credit is simply netted off tax revenue. For a payable credit, at least the part paid out beyond the taxpayer's liability is treated as government expense, typically a social benefit or a subsidy, rather than as negative tax. The choice affects reported tax-to-GDP ratios and makes cross-country comparisons of tax burdens sensitive to whether support is delivered through credits or through direct payments.
Criticism and design issues
Tax credits are praised for targeting support and for using an existing collection system. Critics point to complexity, low take-up among eligible people who do not file returns, and error and fraud in refundable credits, which can involve large payments. Because credits are phased out as income rises, they can create high effective marginal tax rates over the phase-out range, weakening incentives to earn more. Business credits are criticised when they reward activity that would have happened anyway.
External links
Ref 1010001530