Substitution settlement is the settlement of the movements needed to replace one collateral asset with another under a repo, securities loan or margin agreement. Once a collateral substitution request has been agreed, two legs must settle: the collateral taker returns the original securities and the collateral giver delivers the replacement. Both are usually free of payment (FOP) deliveries, and the new collateral must at least match the old in value after haircuts.
The main risk lies in sequencing. If the original collateral is returned before the replacement arrives, the taker is briefly under-secured; if the replacement arrives first, the giver temporarily over-collateralises. Agreements therefore often require the new collateral to be received first, or both legs to be linked. A failed leg is a settlement failure. In tri-party collateral management the agent performs both legs on its own books at the same moment, which largely removes this risk. The underlying concept is described under collateral substitution.