Stock exchange holding groups are companies, usually listed on their own markets, that own one or more exchanges together with the businesses that surround trading: clearing houses, central securities depositories, index providers and market data services. Most were created from the 1990s onwards, when member-owned exchanges demutualised, turned into companies and merged with their local clearing and settlement bodies.
The model allows a group to earn revenue across the whole life of a trade, from listing and trading to clearing, settlement, custody and data, and it has prompted long-running debate about competition and the conflict between running a market for profit and regulating it. Besides the four groups below, others include the London Stock Exchange Group (LSEG), Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), Euronext and the groups behind Nasdaq, the ASX and Singapore Exchange.
Deutsche Börse
Deutsche Börse AG is the Frankfurt-area group that operates Germany's main exchange infrastructure. It runs the Frankfurt Stock Exchange, a public-law institution it operates under licence, and the electronic trading system Xetra, launched in 1997. It also owns the derivatives exchange Eurex and the post-trade group Clearstream, which it took full control of in 2002, along with index, data and investment software businesses. The group listed its own shares in 2001 and is a member of the DAX. It is supervised by BaFin and, for the exchanges, by the exchange supervisory authority of the state of Hesse. Its attempts at large mergers have repeatedly failed: talks with the London Stock Exchange collapsed in 2000 and in 2004 to 2005, a merger with NYSE Euronext was blocked by the European Commission in 2012, and a second agreed merger with the London Stock Exchange was blocked by the Commission in 2017.
Japan Exchange Group (JPX)
Japan Exchange Group (JPX) was formed on 1 January 2013 through the merger of Tokyo Stock Exchange Group and Osaka Securities Exchange. Within the group, cash equity trading was consolidated on the Tokyo Stock Exchange in 2013, and derivatives were moved to Osaka, renamed Osaka Exchange, in 2014, making it the home of Japan's main index futures and options. Japan Securities Clearing Corporation (JSCC) acts as the central counterparty, and the Tokyo Commodity Exchange joined the group in 2019, bringing energy and other commodity futures into the group. JPX's shares are listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange, and the group is supervised by the Financial Services Agency. Its market supports the TOPIX, calculated by a JPX subsidiary, and derivatives on the Nikkei 225. In 2022 the Tokyo Stock Exchange reorganised its listing sections into the Prime, Standard and Growth markets.
Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing (HKEX)
Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing (HKEX) was created in 2000 when the Stock Exchange of Hong Kong, the Hong Kong Futures Exchange and Hong Kong Securities Clearing Company were demutualised and merged under one holding company. HKEX listed its shares on its own market later in 2000, under stock code 388, and is overseen by the Securities and Futures Commission; the Hong Kong government appoints part of its board. The group operates clearing houses for securities, futures, options and over-the-counter derivatives. In 2012 it bought the London Metal Exchange, the world's main market for industrial metals. HKEX is also the Hong Kong side of the Shanghai-Hong Kong Stock Connect, launched in 2014, and the Shenzhen link that followed in 2016, which let investors in Hong Kong and mainland China trade eligible shares on each other's markets. The best-known index of the market, the Hang Seng Index, is compiled by a separate company.
TMX Group
TMX Group is the Canadian group that owns the country's main exchanges and post-trade systems. It took its present name in 2008, when TSX Group, operator of the Toronto Stock Exchange, acquired the Montréal Exchange, Canada's derivatives market. The group also runs the TSX Venture Exchange for early-stage companies, the Canadian Derivatives Clearing Corporation (CDCC) and the Canadian Depository for Securities (CDS). A proposed merger with the London Stock Exchange was abandoned in 2011 in the face of a rival bid by a consortium of Canadian banks and pension funds, the Maple Group, which acquired TMX Group in 2012 and combined it with CDS and the Alpha trading system. TMX Group is regulated by provincial securities commissions, chiefly those of Ontario and Quebec, and its flagship market supports the S&P/TSX Composite Index. It has also expanded into energy market data and trading technology.
Comparison of the groups
| Group | Home market | Main exchanges | Clearing and settlement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deutsche Börse | Germany | Frankfurt Stock Exchange (Xetra), Eurex | Eurex Clearing, Clearstream |
| Japan Exchange Group | Japan | Tokyo Stock Exchange, Osaka Exchange, Tokyo Commodity Exchange | JSCC |
| HKEX | Hong Kong | Stock Exchange of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Futures Exchange, London Metal Exchange | HKSCC and other group clearing houses |
| TMX Group | Canada | Toronto Stock Exchange, TSX Venture Exchange, Montréal Exchange | CDCC, CDS |
External links
Ref 1180001988