Statutory liens and trusts that can outrank lenders are claims on a borrower's property that arise by operation of law rather than by agreement, and that may rank ahead of, or alongside, a lender's security interest. In the United States they include the federal tax lien, liens for landlords, contractors and livestock keepers, grower liens, and two federal statutory trusts for unpaid sellers of produce and livestock.
They matter because a lender's priority normally comes from the rules on attachment, perfection and priority under UCC Article 9, and statutory claims can bypass those rules. Many of these liens are created by state law, so their scope, filing requirements and ranking vary from state to state. Asset-based lenders respond by searching public records, obtaining waivers, and taking reserves that reduce availability under the borrowing base by the amount of claims that could come ahead of them.
Federal Tax Lien
A federal tax lien is a lien in favour of the United States that arises automatically when federal tax has been assessed, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has demanded payment and the taxpayer has failed to pay. It attaches to all the taxpayer's property, including property acquired later. Until the IRS files a Notice of Federal Tax Lien in the appropriate public office, however, the lien is not valid against a holder of a perfected security interest, a purchaser or certain other creditors.
Once a notice is filed, the Federal Tax Lien Act of 1966 governs priority. A lender with a prior perfected security interest keeps priority over existing collateral, and under the 45-day rule its lien on collateral acquired by the borrower within 45 days after the notice filing, under an existing commercial financing agreement, is generally protected if the lender lacks actual knowledge of the filing. Lenders often reserve for unpaid payroll taxes. The IRS issues a certificate of release once the tax is paid and can discharge specific property from the lien.
Landlord's Lien
A landlord's lien is a claim of a landlord over a tenant's goods kept on the leased premises, securing unpaid rent. Some US states grant it by statute, especially for commercial or agricultural tenancies; others recognise it only if the lease agreement creates it, in which case it is a contractual security interest. The traditional remedy of distress, seizing goods for rent, survives only in limited forms. UCC Article 9 generally does not apply to statutory landlord's liens, so their priority over a lender is set by state law.
For inventory and equipment lenders the risk is that a landlord can block access to collateral or claim it ahead of the lender after a default. The usual protection is a landlord waiver, also called a collateral access agreement, in which the landlord subordinates its lien and allows the lender a period to enter the premises and remove collateral. Where no waiver is obtained, asset-based lenders commonly take a rent reserve equal to several months' rent at each location.
Mechanic's Lien
A mechanic's lien, also called a construction lien, is a statutory lien on real property in favour of contractors, subcontractors, labourers and suppliers who provide work or materials that improve it and are not paid. Every US state has a mechanic's lien statute, and the rules vary widely on who qualifies, what notices must be served, and the deadlines for recording the lien and bringing an action to enforce it.
Mechanic's liens are a central risk for construction loans. In many states the lien's priority relates back to the date work first began on the project, so a lien filed months later can rank ahead of a mortgage recorded after work started. Construction lenders protect themselves by checking that no work began before the mortgage was recorded, collecting conditional and unconditional lien waivers from contractors with each draw, using title company date-down endorsements to lender's title insurance, and holding back retainage until lien periods expire. Paid claims are removed by a release of lien.
Agister's Lien
An agister's lien is a statutory lien in favour of a person who feeds, pastures or otherwise cares for another person's livestock, securing the unpaid charges for that care. Agistment, the practice of grazing or feeding animals for a fee, is common in ranching and feedlot operations, and most US states provide an agister's lien by statute, although its terms vary.
In many states the lien depends on the agister keeping possession of the animals. Under UCC Article 9 a possessory lien for services or materials provided in the ordinary course of business generally takes priority over a perfected security interest in the same goods, unless the statute creating the lien says otherwise. Some states also allow non-possessory agister's liens that must be filed to be effective. For an agricultural lender whose security covers the borrower's cattle, an unpaid feedlot bill can therefore rank first. Lenders reduce the risk by monitoring where livestock are kept, obtaining subordination agreements and paying feed bills directly.
Grower Lien
A grower lien is a statutory protection for farmers and other producers who deliver crops or livestock to a buyer, usually a processor, packer or dealer, and are not paid. Several US states grant producers or growers a lien on the products they deliver, on goods made from them and on the sale proceeds; such liens are often agricultural liens under UCC Article 9, which has special rules for their perfection and priority. Federal law adds statutory trusts that work to similar effect, notably the PACA trust for produce and the Packers and Stockyards Act trusts for livestock and poultry.
These protections can prime a lender's security interest in a processor's inventory and receivables, so lenders to food processors, distributors and packers analyse the borrower's unpaid supplier balances and take reserves against them. Where grower liens or trusts apply, a borrower's payables to farmers effectively become a senior claim on its working capital assets. The risk is discussed further in agricultural lending underwriting.
Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA) Trust
The Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA) is a US federal law of 1930 that regulates fair trading in fresh and frozen fruit and vegetables and requires most dealers, commission merchants and brokers to hold a licence from the US Department of Agriculture (USDA). A 1984 amendment created the PACA trust. Produce, products derived from it, and the receivables and proceeds from its sale are held by the buyer in a floating, non-segregated statutory trust for the benefit of unpaid sellers until they are paid in full.
To preserve its rights an unpaid seller must give written notice within set time limits or include the required trust language on its invoices, and payment terms longer than those permitted by regulation can forfeit the protection. Because trust assets do not belong to the buyer, they are not available to its secured lenders and, in bankruptcy, fall outside the estate, which is significant for secured lenders in US bankruptcy. Asset-based lenders to restaurants, grocers and food distributors therefore take a PACA reserve equal to unpaid produce payables.
Packers and Stockyards Act Trust
The Packers and Stockyards Act is a US federal law of 1921 that regulates livestock markets, meat packers, livestock dealers and poultry companies, and is administered by the USDA. Amendments created statutory trusts for unpaid sellers: a packer trust for cash sellers of livestock added in 1976, a poultry trust protecting poultry growers and sellers added in 1987, and a livestock dealer trust created by the Agriculture Improvement Act of 2018.
Under the packer trust, livestock bought by a covered packer, the meat and other products made from it, and the receivables and proceeds are held in trust for unpaid cash sellers until full payment. As with the PACA trust, the trust assets rank ahead of the packer's secured lenders, and sellers must give timely notice to preserve their claim. Small packers below a purchase threshold are exempt. Lenders to meat packers, poultry processors and livestock dealers watch unpaid livestock and grower payables closely and reserve for them in their inventory financing and receivables lines.
How the claims compare
| Claim | Source of law | Typical collateral affected | Lender response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Federal tax lien | Federal statute | All property | Tax monitoring, reserves |
| Landlord's lien | State law or lease | Goods on premises | Landlord waiver, rent reserve |
| Mechanic's lien | State law | Improved real property | Lien waivers, title endorsements |
| Agister's lien | State law | Livestock | Monitoring, subordination |
| Grower lien | State law | Crops, products, proceeds | Payables reserve |
| PACA trust | Federal statute | Produce, products, receivables | PACA reserve |
| Packers and Stockyards trust | Federal statute | Livestock, meat, poultry, receivables | Payables reserve |
External links
Ref 1210000686