Standard Portfolio Analysis of Risk (SPAN) is a method for calculating the margin, or performance bond, required on a portfolio of futures and options. It estimates the largest loss the portfolio is likely to suffer over one day by revaluing every position under a fixed set of market scenarios, and then adjusts the result for spreads and offsets between related contracts. The requirement applies to the portfolio as a whole rather than to each position separately.
SPAN was developed by the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) and introduced in 1988. It became the industry standard for exchange-traded derivatives and has been licensed to many exchanges and clearing houses around the world. Clearing houses use it to set the initial margin that clearing members post, and brokers use the same parameters as the minimum they charge customers.
Risk arrays and scenarios
For each contract the clearing house publishes a risk parameter file. Its two main inputs are the price scan range, the largest price move the clearing house wants to cover with reasonable confidence over the margin period, and the volatility scan range, the largest likely change in implied volatility for options.
SPAN combines these into 16 scenarios. Fourteen move the underlying price up or down by zero, one third, two thirds or the full scan range, each paired with a rise or fall in volatility. The last two are extreme moves, several times the scan range, of which only a fraction of the loss is counted, so that deep out-of-the-money short options do not escape margin. The gain or loss of one contract in each scenario forms its risk array. For futures the array is linear in the price move, while for options on futures it is calculated with an option pricing model, which captures how option values change with price and volatility.
From risk arrays to a margin requirement
The arrays of all positions in one commodity are added up, and the worst total across the 16 scenarios is the scanning risk. SPAN then adds and subtracts several charges and credits:
- Intra-commodity spread charge. Scanning assumes that every month of a contract moves by the same amount, so a calendar spread would look riskless. A charge per spread covers the risk that the months diverge.
- Spot-month charge. An extra amount applies to positions in the delivery month, where prices can be erratic.
- Inter-commodity spread credit. Offsetting positions in related products, such as two grades of crude oil or two interest rate contracts, earn a credit set as a percentage of their scanning risk.
- Short option minimum. A floor per short option ensures that some margin is always charged.
In simplified form, the requirement for a commodity group is:
Here is the scanning risk, the intra-commodity spread charge, the spot-month charge, the inter-commodity spread credit, and the short option minimum. For portfolios with options, the net value of long and short options is then taken into account.
As an example, suppose a trader is long 10 contracts of one crude oil grade with a price scan range of $2,000 each and short 8 contracts of a related grade with a scan range of $2,500. The scanning risk on each side is and dollars, or 40,000 in total. If the clearing house grants a 60 percent inter-commodity credit, . With no other charges and no options, the requirement is dollars.
Place in the margin system
SPAN sets the starting point; daily variation margin then settles gains and losses as prices change, and brokers call for more funds when equity falls below the maintenance margin. Because SPAN looks at the whole portfolio, hedged and spread positions need far less margin than the sum of outright requirements, which links it to the idea behind portfolio margin in securities accounts. Other central counterparties use their own scenario or value-at-risk models, and the Options Clearing Corporation (OCC) developed separate systems for listed equity options.
Limitations and successor methods
SPAN depends on parameters chosen by the clearing house, and a scan range set from past volatility can prove too small in a sudden shock, leading to large intraday margin increases. Its fixed scenarios and spread tables handle simple portfolios well but capture correlations and complex option positions only roughly. CME has been moving products to a successor framework known as SPAN 2, which uses historical value-at-risk methods, though SPAN remains in wide use.