A soulbound token (SBT) is a token that cannot be transferred once it has been issued to a wallet. Where an ordinary non-fungible token (NFT) can be sold or given away, a soulbound token stays with the account it was issued to, which makes it suitable for representing facts about that account's owner: a qualification, a membership, attendance at an event, a completed identity check or a record of past behaviour.
The term borrows from online games, where "soulbound" items cannot be traded once picked up. It was popularised by Vitalik Buterin in early 2022 and set out in detail in the May 2022 paper "Decentralized Society: Finding Web3's Soul" by E. Glen Weyl, Puja Ohlhaver and Buterin. SBTs overlap with the wider field of decentralised identity, which pursues similar goals through other tools.
Origin and concept
The Decentralized Society paper argued that Web3 had focused on transferable, financial assets and lacked a way to express the relationships and commitments that make up social and economic life. It proposed "Souls", accounts holding non-transferable tokens issued by other Souls such as universities, employers and communities. A history of such tokens would let others judge an account's track record, and the authors suggested uses ranging from undercollateralised lending to governance mechanisms that resist manipulation, such as variants of quadratic voting. The paper was a set of proposals rather than a technical standard.
How soulbound tokens work
On Ethereum, most soulbound tokens are built on ERC-721 with transfers disabled. ERC-5192, "Minimal Soulbound NFTs", is a short standard that adds a function reporting whether a token is locked, plus events signalling when it becomes locked or unlocked, so wallets and marketplaces can recognise tokens that cannot move. Other proposals cover tokens bound to an account but burnable by their holder, or revocable by their issuer.
Issuance is normally a mint by the issuer directly to the recipient's address, sometimes only after the recipient has agreed to receive it, since an unwanted token cannot be passed on. A soulbound token proves only that a given issuer made a statement about a wallet; it says nothing about a real-world person unless the issuer checked. Its value therefore depends on knowing and trusting the issuer, which is why proposals often pair SBTs with a decentralized identifier (DID) for issuers. Similar features exist on other chains, and some permissioned token standards achieve the same effect by restricting transfers to approved identities.
Uses
- Credentials. Universities, training bodies or employers can issue tokens recording degrees, certificates or job history, which third parties can check on chain.
- Membership and attendance. Communities issue SBTs to members, and event organisers to attendees, in a similar way to the Proof of Attendance Protocol, whose badges are usually transferable.
- KYC and eligibility. A provider that has completed know your customer (KYC) checks can issue a token stating that a wallet passed, so services can admit it without collecting documents again.
- Reputation and credit. Lending protocols have explored SBTs recording repayment history as an input to uncollateralized loans, a crypto counterpart to a credit score.
- Sybil resistance. Airdrops and governance votes can be restricted to wallets holding proof of a unique person, a form of Sybil resistance linked to proof of personhood.
Risks and criticism
The main concern is privacy. Tokens on a public blockchain are visible to anyone, so a wallet's credentials, memberships and history can be linked and profiled, and some facts, such as health or financial status, should never be public. Designs respond by storing only a reference or commitment on chain, or by combining SBTs with zero-knowledge proofs that reveal a fact without the underlying data. Approaches based on a verifiable credential held off chain avoid putting personal data on a ledger at all.
Key loss is a second problem. If a user loses the private key or seed phrase, tokens that cannot be transferred cannot simply be moved to a new wallet; the paper suggested community-based recovery, and issuers may need to reissue. Other criticisms include the risk of coercion or discrimination based on what a wallet does or does not hold, the difficulty of revoking or correcting a token, and the fact that the token proves only what its issuer asserted. Soulbound tokens have seen use in niche credential and community projects but have not become a mainstream identity layer.
External links
Ref 1070001362