Social return on investment (SROI) is a method for measuring and reporting the social, environmental and economic value created by an organisation, programme or investment, and expressing that value in money terms relative to the resources put in. The result is usually stated as a ratio, such as 3:1, meaning that every unit of currency invested is estimated to generate three units of social value. The net benefit to society that such an analysis tries to capture is often called the social return, as distinct from the financial return earned by the investor.
SROI was developed in the late 1990s by REDF (originally the Roberts Enterprise Development Fund), a San Francisco venture philanthropy fund supporting social enterprises, and was later refined in the United Kingdom, where a government-backed guide was published in 2009. It is used by charities, funders, impact investors and public commissioners. It adapts the logic of cost-benefit analysis but gives stakeholders a central role in deciding which outcomes matter.
Principles and process
The UK framework, now maintained by Social Value International, rests on principles such as involving stakeholders, understanding what changes, valuing the things that matter, including only what is material, not over-claiming, being transparent and verifying the result. A typical analysis moves through these stages:
- Establishing the scope and identifying stakeholders.
- Mapping how inputs lead to outputs and outcomes, usually in an impact map.
- Evidencing outcomes and giving them a value.
- Establishing impact by removing what would have happened anyway or is due to others.
- Calculating the SROI.
- Reporting, using and embedding the results.
An analysis can be evaluative, based on outcomes that have already occurred, or a forecast that predicts the value of planned activities. Forecast analyses are often used at the design stage to choose between options and to set up the data collection needed for a later evaluative study. Good practice is to report the impact map, the sources of every financial proxy and the assumptions used, so that readers can see how the final figure was reached and test alternative values.
Calculating the ratio
Outcomes are valued with financial proxies, a step known as monetisation: for example, the extra earnings of a person who finds a job, savings in public spending, or the value people are estimated to place on improved well-being. Each outcome's value is then adjusted to isolate the organisation's contribution:
- is deadweight, the share of the outcome that would have happened anyway.
- is attribution, the share caused by other organisations or people.
- is displacement, the share that merely moves an outcome from somewhere else.
Impacts that last more than a year are reduced each year by a drop-off rate and discounted to present value with a discount rate, as in a net present value calculation. The ratio is then:
As a worked example, suppose a training programme costs 100,000 and its clients gain 400,000 in extra earnings over one year. If deadweight is 25%, attribution 20% and displacement zero, the impact is . With no later years and no discounting, the SROI is , reported as 2.4:1. A related figure, net SROI, subtracts the investment first: .
Uses
Organisations use SROI to make the case to funders, to compare programme options, to manage toward outcomes and to report to stakeholders. Public-sector commissioners use it to judge social impact in procurement, and some venture philanthropy and social investment funds have used it to screen or monitor portfolios. In microfinance and international development, it has been applied to training, livelihood and health programmes, though less often than survey-based impact assessment. Some organisations combine the two, using survey or experimental evidence to estimate outcomes and SROI only to express them in money terms. The method has also influenced social value requirements in public procurement in the United Kingdom, where commissioners are asked to consider wider social, economic and environmental benefits when awarding contracts.
Criticism and limitations
SROI ratios are highly sensitive to assumptions. The choice of financial proxies, deadweight and attribution rates, duration and drop-off can change the result several times over, so sensitivity analysis is a recommended part of the method. Ratios from different studies are not comparable, because each defines its own scope and proxies, yet they are often presented as if they were. Putting a money value on outcomes such as dignity or confidence is contested, and deadweight estimates rarely come from a true control group. Analyses are costly, and those commissioned by the organisation being assessed risk over-claiming. Supporters respond that the process of engaging stakeholders and mapping change is as valuable as the final number.
External links
Ref 1270000023