The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act is the common name of the Tariff Act of 1930, a United States law that raised import duties on thousands of agricultural and industrial goods. President Herbert Hoover signed it on 17 June 1930. It takes its name from its sponsors in Congress, Senator Reed Smoot of Utah and Representative Willis C. Hawley of Oregon, who chaired the committees responsible for tariff legislation.
The act is the best-known example of protectionism in American history. It took effect in the first year of the Great Depression, was followed by retaliation from trading partners and a collapse in world trade, and has been cited ever since in arguments against raising trade barriers. Historians and economists continue to debate how much of the damage it caused.
Background
American farm prices were weak through the 1920s, and Hoover campaigned in 1928 on a promise to help farmers with higher duties on agricultural imports. US tariffs were already high after the Fordney-McCumber Tariff of 1922. When Congress took up the bill in 1929, members traded votes for protection of industries in their own districts, and a limited farm measure grew into a general upward revision of the tariff schedule.
The bill was still before Congress when the stock market crash of October 1929 occurred. In May 1930, a petition signed by 1,028 economists asked Hoover to veto it, arguing that it would raise prices for consumers, invite retaliation and hurt exporters. Hoover signed it nonetheless.
What the act did
The law increased duties on a wide range of goods, by common estimates about 20,000 items. Many were set as a specific tariff, a fixed sum per unit, and not as an ad valorem tariff charged on value. That detail mattered. As deflation pushed import prices down after 1930, a fixed duty became a larger share of each good's price. The average duty on dutiable imports rose from about 40 percent in 1929 to nearly 60 percent in 1932, and a good part of the increase came from falling prices, not from the new rates themselves. The act also kept a flexible tariff provision, which let the president raise or lower an individual rate by up to 50 percent on the recommendation of the Tariff Commission.
Retaliation and the fall in trade
Foreign governments protested before the bill passed and responded afterwards. Canada, the largest US trading partner, raised duties on American goods and gave preference to British ones. Several European countries imposed new tariffs or quotas on particular products, and in 1932 Britain and its dominions adopted a system of imperial preference at Ottawa.
Trade shrank sharply. US imports fell from about $4.4 billion in 1929 to about $1.5 billion in 1933, and exports fell from about $5.4 billion to about $2.1 billion. World trade as a whole declined by roughly two-thirds in value between 1929 and 1934.
Economic assessment
The prevailing view among economists is that the act deepened the Depression but did not cause it. Trade was a small part of the American economy at the time, with imports equal to only a few percent of output. Most research gives greater weight to the banking crises, the contraction of the money supply and the constraints of the gold standard. A large share of the fall in trade is also explained by collapsing incomes and prices, which would have reduced trade under any tariff.
The act is nevertheless judged to have done harm. It raised costs for firms that used imported inputs, damaged exporters when other countries retaliated, and soured economic diplomacy when cooperation was needed. Share prices fell on several occasions as the bill advanced through Congress, which some writers read as a sign that investors expected it to do damage. Both sponsors lost their seats in the 1932 elections.
Legacy
The law changed how the United States made trade policy. The Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act of 1934 moved the setting of tariff rates from Congress to the president, who could cut duties through negotiated agreements. After the Second World War the same approach was applied multilaterally in the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade and later the World Trade Organization.
The Tariff Act of 1930 was never repealed. Its rates were reduced by later agreements, but much of the statute still forms the base of US customs law, including provisions on unfair import practices and on anti-dumping duties. The name returns to public debate whenever broad tariff increases are proposed, as in discussion of the reciprocal tariff.