The Shared National Credit (SNC) Program is a supervisory programme run jointly by the Federal Reserve Board, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) to review the largest and most complex loans held by more than one regulated institution. Instead of each agency examining its own banks' share of the same syndicated loan, examiners from the three agencies review the credit once and assign a single rating that applies to every supervised holder.
The programme was set up in 1977. It gives supervisors a consistent view of credit risk in the large corporate loan market, reduces duplicated examination work and lets the agencies track trends across the system, particularly in leveraged loans. It is a US programme; other countries' supervisors review large exposures through their own examination processes.
Which credits are covered
Since 1 January 2018, a shared national credit has been any loan or formal loan commitment, or group of related commitments to the same borrower, with an aggregate amount of at least $100 million that is shared by three or more federally supervised institutions under a single credit agreement. Before that date the threshold was $20 million. The definition counts commitments, not only drawn balances, so an undrawn revolving facility can qualify. It also captures credits arranged in the loan syndication market and later sold down, provided at least three supervised institutions still hold pieces.
The holdings of non-bank investors such as collateralised loan obligations, insurance companies and finance companies are not themselves supervised through the programme, but the agencies collect data on them. Published results have often noted that non-banks hold a large share of the weakest-rated commitments.
How the review works
The agent bank for each credit reports data on the facility, its commitments and the identity of the holders. Examiners then select a sample for detailed review, weighted towards larger, riskier and leveraged credits. They read the credit file, financial statements and projections, test repayment capacity and collateral, and meet the agent bank's credit officers. The process draws on the agent's own internal risk rating but does not have to agree with it.
The agencies currently carry out reviews twice a year, with a fuller review in one period and a narrower one in the other. Ratings are shared with the agent and participating banks, which are expected to reflect them in their own books, provisioning and credit administration.
Ratings
Each reviewed credit is placed in the standard US supervisory classification used for commercial loans:
- Pass. The credit shows no weakness that needs supervisory attention.
- Special mention. The credit has potential weaknesses that could weaken repayment if left uncorrected.
- Substandard. Well-defined weaknesses put repayment at risk, with a distinct possibility of loss if they are not corrected.
- Doubtful. Full collection is highly questionable, though the exact loss is not yet known.
- Loss. The amount is considered uncollectible and should be charged off.
Credits rated special mention or worse are described as criticised; those rated substandard, doubtful or loss are classified. Classified balances are closely related to the non-performing loan category, though a classified loan may still be paying on time. A credit whose rating falls is often moved into a lender's problem loan and workout process.
Published findings and uses
The agencies publish a summary of each year's results, giving total commitments, the share criticised and classified, the distribution by industry and type of holder, and comments on underwriting standards. Over the years these reports have repeatedly highlighted weak structures in leveraged lending, including high leverage multiples, limited covenants and reliance on optimistic projections, and they have been one input into the agencies' guidance on leveraged buyout financing. Banks use the results to benchmark their own ratings and concentration risk, and market participants read them as a broad indicator of credit quality in large corporate lending.
Relationship to bank credit management
The programme does not replace a bank's own credit process. Each participant remains responsible for underwriting its share, monitoring the borrower and assigning its own grade, using the roles and documents described under syndicated loan roles and documents. Where the SNC rating is worse than a bank's internal grade, examiners expect the bank to adopt it or to justify the difference. In practice, the agent bank's analysis and the quality of its credit file shape the result for every lender in the syndicate.
External links
Ref 1050000797