Selling collateral after default under UCC Article 9 is the main remedy of a US secured lender whose loan is backed by personal property such as equipment, inventory, receivables or shares. Part 6 of Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, adopted in every state, lets the secured party take possession of the collateral after default and dispose of it, apply the proceeds to the debt, and then pursue the debtor for any shortfall or pay any surplus to the debtor or to junior creditors.
The right is powerful because it does not require a court judgment, but it comes with duties. Every aspect of the disposition must be commercially reasonable, and the debtor, guarantors and certain other creditors must receive reasonable notice. The sale may be public or private. The rules below describe commercial transactions; sales of consumer goods carry extra protections. Real estate is outside Article 9 and is enforced through foreclosure under state law.
Article 9 Sale
An Article 9 sale is the disposition of collateral by a secured party after the debtor’s default, under section 9-610 of the UCC. The lender may first take possession through repossession without court action, provided it does not breach the peace, or may sell collateral that it controls or that remains in the debtor’s premises. It may sell, lease or license the collateral in its present condition or after reasonable preparation, as a whole or in parts, by public or private disposition.
Proceeds go first to the costs of taking, holding and selling the collateral, then to the secured debt, and then to subordinate secured parties that have made a proper demand. The buyer takes the debtor’s rights free of the selling lender’s security interest and junior interests. Article 9 sales are also used in distressed mergers and acquisitions: a lender holding a pledge of a company’s shares can sell them to a new owner quickly, without a bankruptcy case, often after negotiation with the debtor.
Commercially Reasonable
Commercially reasonable is the standard that every aspect of a secured party’s disposition of collateral must meet under Article 9, including the method, manner, time, place and other terms. The code does not define the phrase exhaustively, but section 9-627 gives guidance. A disposition is commercially reasonable if it is made in the usual manner on a recognised market, at the current price in such a market, or otherwise in conformity with reasonable commercial practices among dealers in that kind of property. A low price alone does not make a sale unreasonable, though it may prompt closer scrutiny.
Courts look at factors such as advertising, the number of potential buyers contacted, the condition of the goods and the timing of the sale. If the lender fails to comply, in a commercial case the rebuttable presumption rule applies: the lender’s deficiency claim is reduced to the extent that a proper sale would have produced more, and the lender bears the burden of proving what that amount would have been.
Notice of Sale
A notice of sale is the written notification of disposition that a secured party must send before selling collateral under Article 9, unless the collateral is perishable, threatens to decline quickly in value, or is of a type customarily sold on a recognised market. In a commercial transaction it must go to the debtor, any secondary obligor such as a guarantor, and other secured parties and lienholders that have notified the lender of their claim or have filed a financing statement against the debtor.
The notice must describe the debtor, the secured party and the collateral, state the method of disposition, and give the time and place of a public sale or the time after which a private sale will be made. Section 9-612 provides a safe harbour: in a non-consumer transaction, notice sent at least ten days before the earliest time of disposition is treated as sent within a reasonable time. Before the sale, the debtor may redeem the collateral by paying the full debt and costs.
Public Auction
A public auction is a disposition of collateral at a sale open to the public, announced in advance with a time and place so that bidders can compete. Article 9 does not define the term, but the official commentary treats a public disposition as one where the price is determined after the public has had a meaningful opportunity to bid, following public notice. Any other method, such as a negotiated sale to a dealer or a sale through a broker, is a private disposition.
The difference matters for the lender’s right to buy. A secured party may buy the collateral at a public disposition, often by credit bidding the amount of its debt. At a private disposition it may buy only collateral of a kind customarily sold on a recognised market or subject to widely distributed standard price quotations, such as listed shares. Private sales often achieve better prices for specialised equipment or businesses, while public auctions provide a transparent price and allow the lender to take ownership.
If the proceeds fall short of the debt, the debtor and any guarantor generally remain liable for the deficiency; if they exceed it, the surplus must be paid to junior claimants and then to the debtor. Instead of selling, a lender may propose to keep the collateral in full or partial satisfaction of the debt, known as strict foreclosure, if the debtor and other interested parties do not object. Where the collateral is part of a business in financial distress, a sale under bankruptcy law or through receivership may replace an Article 9 sale. The rules on how a lender obtains its rights in the first place are described in attachment, perfection and priority under UCC Article 9, and the kinds of property covered in collateral types under UCC Article 9.
Ref 1210000685