In crypto, security vs. commodity classification is the question, mainly under United States law, of whether a given crypto asset or a transaction in it is a security or a commodity. The answer decides which federal regulator has primary authority, which registration and disclosure rules apply to the issuer, and what licences exchanges, brokers and custodians need to deal in the asset.
If an asset is offered as a security, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) oversees it under the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. If it is a commodity, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regulates derivatives on it under the Commodity Exchange Act and can pursue fraud and manipulation in the spot market. For most of the industry's history neither statute was written with crypto in mind, so the line has been drawn by court cases, enforcement actions and agency statements.
The Howey test
US securities law lists the instruments that count as securities, including the broad category of an "investment contract". In SEC v. W. J. Howey Co. (1946), the Supreme Court defined an investment contract as an investment of money in a common enterprise with an expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others. The Howey test looks at the economic reality of a transaction rather than its label, so calling a token a utility token does not by itself take it outside securities law.
Applied to crypto, the test asks how a token was sold, to whom, with what promises, and how far its value depends on a promoter's continuing work. Many initial coin offerings of 2017 and 2018 met these elements, since buyers paid money to a team that promised to build the network that would make the tokens valuable. The SEC's 2017 report on The DAO applied the same reasoning to tokens issued by a decentralized autonomous organization.
Assets treated as commodities
The Commodity Exchange Act defines commodities very widely, and the CFTC has taken the position since 2015 that bitcoin and other virtual currencies are commodities. Courts have accepted that view. Bitcoin, which has no issuer or promoter whose efforts drive its value, is generally accepted as a commodity rather than a security, and regulated futures on bitcoin and ether trade on CFTC-registered exchanges.
An asset can also change character. Regulators and courts have recognised that a token first sold in an investment contract may later trade in circumstances where buyers no longer rely on a central team, an idea often discussed under the heading of decentralization. The relevant question is then whether a particular sale or offer is a securities transaction, not whether the token is permanently one thing or the other.
Key cases
Several court decisions shaped the debate:
- SEC v. Telegram (2020). A federal court stopped the distribution of Telegram's Gram tokens, treating the pre-sale and the planned resale as one scheme to distribute securities.
- SEC v. LBRY (2022). The court found that LBRY's sales of its LBC tokens were securities offerings, rejecting the argument that a token with real use cannot be a security.
- SEC v. Ripple Labs. The SEC sued Ripple in December 2020 over sales of XRP. In July 2023 the court held that direct sales to institutional buyers were investment contracts, but that programmatic sales on exchanges to anonymous buyers and other distributions were not. A civil penalty followed in 2024, and the remaining appeals were dropped in 2025.
- SEC v. Terraform Labs. Courts held that tokens in the Terra ecosystem were offered as securities, and a jury found Terraform and its founder liable for fraud in 2024.
The split result in the Ripple case, where the same asset was treated differently depending on how it was sold, showed how classification turns on the facts of each transaction.
Policy changes from 2025
In early 2025 the SEC changed course. It set up a crypto task force, withdrew or settled a number of enforcement cases against exchanges and token issuers, and began issuing staff statements on whether activities such as meme coins, staking and some stablecoins involve securities. In July 2025 the GENIUS Act created a federal framework for payment stablecoins and placed qualifying ones outside the definitions of security and commodity.
Congress has also worked on a broader market-structure law that would allocate authority between the two agencies. The CLARITY Act passed the House of Representatives in July 2025; it would give the CFTC authority over spot markets in a new category of digital commodities tied to mature, decentralised networks, while leaving fundraising by issuers under SEC rules. As of October 2026 it had not become law: on 15 September 2026 a Senate vote to begin debate on the bill failed 49–50, short of the 60 votes needed. Its progress in the Senate, and any differences with the Senate's own drafts, are covered in the entry on the act.
Practical consequences
Classification affects every part of a crypto business. An issuer selling a security must register the offering or use an exemption such as Regulation D. A platform listing securities may need to register as an exchange, broker-dealer or alternative trading system, while one dealing in commodity derivatives needs CFTC registration. Firms therefore run legal reviews of each asset before listing it, and uncertainty over the line has been a long-running source of litigation and of arguments for clearer legislation.
External links
Ref 1210000535