What is Return on Capital Employed?
Definition: Return on capital employed is a profitability ratio that divides a company's operating profit by the long-term capital used to run the business, showing how much profit each unit of capital earns.
Return on capital employed (ROCE) is a financial ratio that measures how efficiently a company turns the capital tied up in its business into operating profit. It is usually calculated as EBIT, earnings before interest and tax, divided by capital employed, which is total assets minus current liabilities. Analysts, lenders and managers use it to compare businesses of different size and financing, and to judge whether a company earns more on its capital than that capital costs.
ROCE belongs to the family of profitability ratios and is a close relative of return on equity (ROE) and return on assets (ROA). Its distinguishing feature is that it looks at all long-term funding, both shareholders' equity and non-current debt, and uses a profit figure before interest. This makes it largely neutral to how a company is financed. It is particularly popular in the United Kingdom and Europe and in the analysis of capital-intensive industries.
Formula and worked example
The standard calculation is:
Capital employed is normally defined as:
- is operating profit before interest and tax, taken from the income statement for the year.
- is everything the company owns, from the balance sheet.
- are obligations due within a year, such as trade payables and short-term debt.
Because the balance sheet balances, the same figure equals shareholders' equity plus non-current liabilities. Suppose a manufacturer reports EBIT of 12 million in a year. Its total assets are 100 million and its current liabilities are 40 million, so capital employed is 60 million. ROCE is 12 divided by 60, or 20%. A rival with EBIT of 15 million but capital employed of 100 million has a ROCE of 15%: it earns more profit in absolute terms, but less on each unit of capital.
Many analysts use the average of opening and closing capital employed for the year, so that capital raised or spent during the year is not over- or under-counted. Some deduct surplus cash from capital employed, on the view that idle cash is not used in operations.
Comparison with ROE, ROA and ROIC
Each return ratio puts a different profit figure over a different capital base:
- ROE divides net income by shareholders' equity. It is the owners' view of return, and it rises with borrowing, so two companies with identical operations can show very different ROE.
- ROA divides profit by total assets, including assets funded by short-term liabilities such as supplier credit.
- ROCE divides pre-interest profit by equity plus long-term debt, so it judges the operating business regardless of the mix of debt and equity.
- Return on invested capital (ROIC) usually divides after-tax operating profit by the operating capital invested, excluding surplus cash and non-operating assets, and is the ratio most often set against the cost of capital in valuation work.
ROCE is simple to compute from published accounts, which is part of its appeal. Its pre-tax profit figure also makes companies in different tax regimes easier to compare. The main test is whether ROCE exceeds the weighted average cost of capital (WACC). A business that earns persistently less than its WACC is destroying value even if it reports a profit.
Use in capital-intensive industries
ROCE is most informative where large amounts of fixed capital are needed to produce profit: utilities, telecoms, oil and gas, mining, chemicals, airlines and heavy manufacturing. In these sectors the quality of capital allocation, such as which plants to build and which projects to approve, drives long-run returns, and ROCE shows the results. Investors track the trend of a company's ROCE over a cycle and compare it with peers, while managers use it to rank divisions and new capital expenditure plans against a hurdle rate.
ROCE can also be split into two parts: operating margin, which is EBIT over sales, and capital turnover, which is sales over capital employed. A low-margin retailer and a high-margin software firm can reach the same ROCE by very different routes, in the same way that DuPont analysis splits ROE.
Limitations
ROCE depends on accounting book values, and these can mislead. A company with old, heavily depreciated plant shows small capital employed and therefore a flattering ROCE, even if replacing the plant would cost far more. A company that has just invested heavily shows the opposite. Acquisitions add goodwill to capital employed, while businesses built from within carry little, so ROCE can favour organic growers. Large cash balances inflate capital employed and depress the ratio unless they are removed.
Definitions also vary. Some analysts use operating profit after certain one-off items, some use year-end rather than average capital, and lease accounting changes have moved large amounts of leased assets and liabilities onto balance sheets. ROCE figures should therefore be compared only when calculated on the same basis, and are best read over several years rather than from a single period.
Ref 1010001595