Reservation prices and bargaining power are the ideas economists use to explain the terms of a deal between one buyer and one seller, such as the sale of a house, a used car or a business, or a wage negotiation. Each side has a limit beyond which it will walk away: the most the buyer will pay and the least the seller will accept. If the buyer's limit is above the seller's, a deal can be made, and the difference between the two is the total gain from trade to be shared.
Where the final price falls between those limits depends on bargaining power. The same ideas appear in auctions, in labor markets through the reservation wage, and in the measurement of consumer surplus. The sections below cover the reservation price, willingness to accept and bargaining power.
Reservation Price
A reservation price is the highest price a buyer is prepared to pay for something, or the lowest price a seller is prepared to accept. For the buyer it equals their willingness to pay; for the seller it is set by what the item is worth to them or by their best alternative. Suppose a buyer would pay up to $12,000 for a used car and the owner would accept no less than $9,000. Any price between the two benefits both, and the bargaining range is dollars. At a price of $11,000 the buyer gains dollars and the seller dollars, together equal to the full $3,000. If the buyer's reservation price were below the seller's, no deal would make both better off. In auctions, the seller's reservation price is often published or kept secret as a reserve price, below which the item will not be sold.
Willingness to Accept (WTA)
Willingness to accept (WTA) is the minimum amount of money a person needs to receive to give up a good they own, or to agree to bear a harm such as noise or a health risk. It is the counterpart of willingness to pay, which measures the most a person would pay to get a good or avoid a harm. Standard theory predicts that for ordinary goods the two should be close. Experiments show WTA is often much higher. In a well-known 1990 study by Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler, people given a coffee mug asked for about twice as much to sell it as others would pay to buy one. This gap is linked to the endowment effect and loss aversion: people value what they have more than what they could gain. The choice between WTA and WTP matters in cost-benefit analysis, for example when valuing environmental damage to local residents.
Bargaining Power
Bargaining power is the ability of one party to a deal to capture a larger share of the gains from trade. It depends mainly on each side's outside option, the best alternative if talks fail: a seller with several interested buyers, or a worker with another job offer, can hold out for better terms. Patience, information, the cost of delay and the ability to make credible threats also matter. In game theory, John Nash's 1950 bargaining solution predicts how two parties split a surplus based on what each would get if no agreement is reached, and related models extend the Nash equilibrium idea to offers made over time. In labor markets, trade unions raise workers' bargaining power by bargaining collectively, while monopsony employers hold the advantage where workers have few alternatives. In business, large retailers and dominant suppliers use buyer and supplier power to set terms, part of wider market power.
How the three concepts relate
| Concept | What it measures | Role in a deal |
|---|---|---|
| Reservation price | Each side's walk-away price | Sets the range in which a deal is possible |
| Willingness to accept | Minimum payment to give up a good or bear a harm | Defines the seller's or harmed party's limit |
| Bargaining power | Ability to capture the gains | Decides where in the range the price falls |
Ref 1100001731