Receivables eligibility in asset-based lending is the set of rules that decides which of a borrower's accounts receivable count towards its borrowing base. Lenders advance against receivables because they turn into cash quickly when customers pay, but only if the invoice represents goods actually delivered or services performed, is owed by a customer able to pay, and can be collected without being reduced by disputes or offsets. Any receivable that fails those tests is excluded as ineligible, or included only after a reserve.
The rules are written into the facility agreement and checked through borrowing base certificates and field examinations. Some exclusions relate to timing, such as prebilling and bill and hold arrangements; some to contract structure, such as progress billings and retainage; some to the customer relationship, such as contra accounts and cross-aging; and some to the legal status of the debtor, such as US government receivables. The cut-off dates and percentages differ between agreements and lenders, so the figures below are examples rather than market standards. Eligibility of stock is covered in inventory eligibility in asset-based lending.
Bill and Hold
A bill and hold arrangement is one in which a seller invoices a customer for goods but keeps them in its own warehouse until the customer asks for delivery. Customers may want this when they lack storage space or wish to lock in a price, and sellers may record the sale early. Accounting standards allow revenue to be recognised in such cases only under strict conditions, including a substantive reason for the arrangement and goods that are identified, ready and set aside for the customer; the rules are set out in IFRS 15 and its US equivalent. Asset-based lenders nevertheless usually treat bill and hold receivables as ineligible. The customer has not yet taken the goods, may refuse them or dispute the invoice, and the same goods may also appear in the borrower's inventory, creating a risk that the collateral is counted twice. Bill and hold sales have also featured in accounting frauds, which adds to lender caution.
Prebilling
Prebilling is the practice of issuing an invoice before goods are shipped or services are performed. A borrower might prebill to smooth its cash flow, to meet a customer's budget timetable or, in a weak position, to inflate its borrowing base. Because the customer does not yet owe anything for performance that has not happened, a prebilled invoice is not a true receivable: if the seller fails to deliver, the customer has no duty to pay. Asset-based lenders therefore exclude prebilled amounts from eligible receivables and look for them during field examinations by comparing invoice dates with shipping records and proof of delivery. A pattern of prebilling discovered during an audit is a serious warning sign, since it may point to deliberate misreporting on the borrowing base certificate rather than a simple timing error, and it often leads to tighter reporting and an increase in dilution reserves.
Progress Billing
Progress billing is invoicing in stages as work on a long contract moves forward, common in construction, engineering, shipbuilding and large software projects. The contractor bills, for example, 20 percent of the contract price when foundations are finished and further amounts at later milestones. Lenders are wary of these receivables because payment depends on the contractor completing the whole job: if the borrower fails, the customer can withhold payment, claim damages for delay or hire another firm and set the cost off against amounts owed. A lender trying to collect after a default may find that little of the billed amount is recoverable. As a result, asset-based facilities often treat progress billings as ineligible or allow them only at a reduced advance rate, sometimes with a separate cap. Lenders that specialise in contractor finance look closely at the contract terms, completion percentage and any performance bonds before giving them value.
Retainage
Retainage, also known as retention, is the part of each contract payment that a customer holds back until a project is finished and accepted, as security for the quality of the work. In construction, retainage of between 5 and 10 percent of each progress payment is common, though contracts and some laws set different levels. The withheld amount appears as a receivable on the contractor's books, but it will not be paid until completion, and the customer may use it to pay for defects or unfinished work. For these reasons asset-based lenders almost always treat retainage receivables as ineligible. A business with large retainage balances can therefore have much less borrowing capacity than its total receivables suggest. In receivables finance more broadly, the word retention has a different meaning, referring to the portion of an invoice's value a factor holds back from the client.
Contra Account
In asset-based lending, a contra account is a customer that is also a supplier to the borrower, so the borrower both sells to it and buys from it. The term is distinct from a contra account in bookkeeping, which offsets another account on the ledger. The risk is offset: if the borrower runs into trouble, the customer can set the amount the borrower owes it against what it owes the borrower and pay only the difference, a right of offset that may exist in law or in the contract. For example, if a customer owes the borrower $300,000 and the borrower owes the same firm $120,000 for raw materials, only $180,000 is reliably collectable. Lenders therefore exclude the overlapping amount, or the customer's whole balance, from eligible receivables, or take a reserve equal to the payables owed to that customer. Field examiners compare the receivables and payables ledgers to find such overlaps.
Cross-Aging
Cross-aging is a borrowing base rule under which all of a customer's receivables become ineligible once a set share of that customer's balance is past the ageing cut-off. A typical agreement might treat invoices more than 90 days past invoice date, or 60 days past due, as ineligible, and add a cross-aging rule at a level such as 50 percent; the actual figures vary by agreement. The reasoning is that a customer which has failed to pay a large part of its older invoices is likely to be in difficulty or in dispute, so its newer invoices are also doubtful. For example, if a customer owes $1 million, of which $600,000 is more than 90 days old, a 50 percent cross-aging rule makes the entire $1 million ineligible, not just the $600,000. Lenders track this through an ageing report of the receivables ledger.
Assignment of Claims Act
The Assignment of Claims Act is a United States federal law, enacted in 1940, that sets the conditions under which a contractor may assign the right to payments under a US government contract to a bank or other financing institution. Without it, a government debtor would generally not be bound by an assignment, so a lender could not be sure of collecting. Under the Act the assignment must cover all amounts payable under the contract, be made to a single financing institution (or an agent for several), and be notified in writing to the contracting officer, the disbursing officer and any surety. Many government contracts can be assigned only if the contract allows it. Asset-based lenders therefore count receivables owed by US federal agencies as eligible only after the Act's requirements have been met, or treat them as ineligible or place them under a separate cap. The interaction with Uniform Commercial Code rules on assignment of receivables is a specialist area.
How the exclusions compare
| Category | Main risk | Usual treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Bill and hold | Goods not delivered; double counting with inventory | Ineligible |
| Prebilling | No performance yet | Ineligible |
| Progress billing | Payment depends on completion | Ineligible or limited |
| Retainage | Payable only on completion | Ineligible |
| Contra account | Offset against payables | Excluded or reserved |
| Cross-aging | Customer credit or dispute | Whole balance ineligible |
| US government receivables | Assignment not binding without compliance | Eligible only after compliance |
Reporting and testing of these rules are covered in collateral monitoring and field examinations in asset-based lending.
Ref 1310000586