Home / Wiki / P / Procyclicality

Procyclicality

Economics Markets and Financial TheoryUpdated 16 Nov 2026

Procyclicality is the tendency of the financial system, and of the rules, risk measures and practices within it, to reinforce the swings of the economic and market cycle instead of damping them. In good times, rising asset prices, low measured risk and easy credit encourage more lending and borrowing. In a downturn the same mechanisms work in reverse, forcing deleveraging, asset sales and tighter credit just when the economy is weakest, which deepens the business cycle.

The idea became central to financial regulation after the 2008 financial crisis, as a main concern of macroprudential policy. In the field of financial market infrastructures it has a narrower meaning: risk controls such as margin requirements and collateral haircuts that tighten sharply when markets turn volatile and loosen when they calm, in a way that can itself destabilise markets. Margin set by a central counterparty (CCP) is the clearest example.

01

Sources of procyclicality

  • Risk-sensitive capital rules. When estimated default probabilities fall in a boom, risk-weighted assets and capital requirements fall too, freeing capacity to lend; in a recession they rise.
  • Loan-loss provisioning. Incurred-loss accounting recognised losses late in the cycle. The expected credit loss model introduced under IFRS 9 was meant to act earlier, though it can still raise provisions abruptly at the start of a downturn.
  • Fair value accounting. Under mark-to-market valuation, falling prices reduce reported capital at once, prompting further sales.
  • Margins and haircuts. Models calibrated on recent volatility ask for little collateral in calm markets and much more in stressed ones.
  • Leverage and ratings. Borrowing tends to build up in booms, and rating downgrades in a downturn can trigger collateral calls and forced selling.
02

Margin and haircut spirals

Collateral requirements can create a self-reinforcing loop. A price shock raises volatility, so initial margin and collateral haircuts increase; firms sell assets or cut lending to meet the calls; the sales push prices down and volatility up again. Markus Brunnermeier and Lasse Pedersen described this interaction between market liquidity and funding liquidity in an influential 2009 paper. Large variation margin calls add to the pressure, because they must be paid in cash at short notice even though they reflect price moves rather than higher risk.

The episode most often cited is the turmoil of March 2020 at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, sometimes called the dash for cash. Initial margin at many CCPs rose sharply within days and variation margin flows reached record levels, placing heavy liquidity demands on clearing members and their clients. A review of margining practices by the BCBS, CPMI and IOSCO, published in 2022, examined these events and identified further work on the transparency, predictability and responsiveness of margin models and on the liquidity preparedness of market participants.

03

Anti-procyclicality tools for margin

Principle 6 of the PFMI asks CCPs to adopt stable and conservative margin requirements that limit procyclicality, and Principle 5 asks for haircuts calibrated to include stressed market conditions. In the European Union, technical standards under the European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) are more specific. A CCP must apply at least one of three tools:

  • A buffer of at least 25 per cent of calculated margin, which the CCP may temporarily run down when requirements rise sharply.
  • A weight of at least 25 per cent on stressed observations in the look-back period used to calibrate margin.
  • A floor ensuring margin is no lower than it would be using volatility estimated over a ten-year look-back period.

A simple margin model shows how a buffer works. Initial margin per unit of position is often set as:

M=zα×σ×hM = z_{\alpha} \times \sigma \times \sqrt{h}

Here zαz_{\alpha} is the standard normal value for the confidence level (2.326 at 99 per cent), σ\sigma is the daily volatility of the position's value in per cent, and hh is the margin period of risk in days. With a two-day horizon and daily volatility of 1 per cent, margin is 2.326×1×2=2.326×1.414≈3.292.326 \times 1 \times \sqrt{2} = 2.326 \times 1.414 \approx 3.29 per cent of the position. If volatility triples to 3 per cent, margin triples to about 3×3.29≈9.873 \times 3.29 \approx 9.87 per cent. A CCP holding a 25 per cent buffer would have charged 1.25×3.29≈4.111.25 \times 3.29 \approx 4.11 per cent in calm conditions and could release the buffer in stress, so members face a rise from 4.11 to 9.87 per cent, about 2.4 times rather than three times.

04

Countercyclical tools for banks

Basel III introduced the countercyclical capital buffer, an extra requirement of generally between zero and 2.5 per cent of risk-weighted assets that national authorities raise when credit growth is judged excessive and can cut in a downturn, releasing capital for lending. In March 2020 the Bank of England's Financial Policy Committee reduced the UK rate to zero. Other tools include the capital conservation buffer, leverage ratios that do not fall with measured risk, through-the-cycle estimates of default probabilities, and supervisory stress testing against severe scenarios regardless of current conditions.

05

Trade-offs

Reducing procyclicality has costs. Conservative margins and buffers tie up more collateral and capital in calm periods, raising the cost of hedging and lending, while models that respond slowly can leave a CCP or bank under-protected when risk genuinely changes. There is also a tension between risk sensitivity, which regulators sought to increase after earlier crises, and stability, which favours rules that move less. Measuring procyclicality is difficult in itself, since it requires separating the effect of rules from the underlying cycle.

Last updated 16 Nov 2026